
This speech, abridged for limited time, was delivered to the NCP’s celebration on 21 Nov by a Consistent Democrats speaker. This is the full version.
I bring greetings from the Consistent Democrats and the Liaison Committee for the Fourth International to this meeting to celebrate the 1917 Revolution in November, though it is traditionally referred to as the October Revolution – a quirk of different calendars. For Marxists, Leninists and Trotskyists, this was the greatest event so far in human history. For the first time, the working class took state power for itself as a class, and managed to keep it, collectivising the means of production that previously belonged to the capitalists. For the Bolsheviks, this was the opening of a struggle to abolish capitalism internationally, by revolutionary means, for which the Communist International was created as a world party.
The Russian Empire that was driven to revolution through the trials of the First World War, was the most economically backward of the warring imperialist countries, and therefore was the weak link of imperialism, the first to fall to the working class. The biggest problem the Russian Revolution faced was that, because of the weakness of the Tsarist regime and the Russian capitalists, it was the easiest for the working class to take power, but at the same time the most difficult to hold power, precisely because of the same economic backwardness.
That, plus (so far) the inability of the working class to take power in the more advanced imperialist countries, was the reason why the first workers’ state regressed. From a revolutionary workers organisation with state power (which is what a workers’ state is), led by revolutionaries in the first decade of so, to something that resembled a bureaucratic trade union with state power from the 1930s onwards. That led to a slow decline, and eventually to collapse.
Throughout its history, there were mighty examples of heroism in the defence of the revolution, such as the Civil War in 1918-21, when the early Soviet state fought off over a dozen imperialist armies as well as the domestic White Guards, like Admiral Kolchak, General Deniken and Baron Wrangel, counterrevolutionary warlords who were armed to the teeth by imperialism. They still lost, and the working-class forces won. Even during the period of decline, such heroic resistance was still possible when imperialism attacked the USSR, which it was always looking to do. Hitler’s rise to power in Germany meant such a war – Trotsky called him a super-Wrangel, the deadliest enemy the USSR faced. Fighting off the Nazi invasion cost 27 million Soviet citizens, 20 million or so of which were Russians. It took the most intolerable suffering to stop the imperialist attack.
The USSR did so in an alliance with British and US imperialism, to combat the Third Reich, Fascist Italy and imperial Japan. Yet even after that war, some of their supposed allies, Churchill for one, wanted to start a war to reconquer the USSR for capitalism, though that was completely impractical at the time. The imperialists were never reconciled to the existence of the USSR.
After WWII, they appeared to face an even bigger problem, as the wider context of the USSR’s victory over Hitler led to the emergence of new workers states. Not only in the parts of East Europe and Korea that were directly liberated by the Red Army, but also under their own steam, through leftist guerrilla movements, such as in Yugoslavia, China, Vietnam and Cuba. These put the imperialists on the defensive, though they were fortunate in one sense that none of these new workers states were led by parties that had the world-revolutionary outlook of the Bolsheviks.
Nevertheless, the imperialists were never reconciled to them, they always fought them and threatened them with nuclear war sporadically over Korea and the Cuban missile crisis, then with their defeat in Vietnam they had to back off and institute a short-lived détente in the 1970s, then back to overt nuclear threats in the 1980s. This broke the back of the Soviet bureaucracy, leading to the collapse of East Europe and Germany reunification, and then the collapse of the USSR itself between 1989-1991.
The imperialists thought they had won the jackpot. One of their ideologues proclaimed the End of History. And their client Yeltsin imposed a massive neoliberal economic shock on Russia, that led to a five year fall in life expectancy. Millions died from malnutrition, homelessness, freezing to death, or despairing alcohol abuse. They expanded NATO and bought up the East European buffer countries with the aim of economically conquering and splitting up Russia.
And yet the counterrevolution stalled, and effectively failed. Because the neoliberal attack fuelled a huge popular backlash. And that was expressed through the old bureaucracy, which could not simply be magicked away. And it appears that that same bureaucracy manoeuvred Yeltsin out of power, and replaced him with Putin, a man of the old apparatus. Who has rolled back many of the neoliberal attacks, and put many of the privateers in prison, or worse! So, while Russia today is not a workers’ state, its form of capitalism has massive deformations from the period of the USSR, and the Western bourgeoisie hate it.
And above all, they hate its de-facto alliance with China, which is still a deformed workers’ state. Unfortunately, in the last few decades of the USSR, a huge dispute between the USSR and China meant that China helped the US to defeat the USSR. That regrettable antagonism is no more today, which makes the Russia-China block much more powerful and the combination is pulling ahead technologically. The imperialists hate this. This is why we see the demented Russophobia today. This is why we see the war threats against Russia.
Even the so-called liberal bourgeoisie in the West, the Joe Bidens, the Macrons, the Andy Burnhams, now believe that Hitler was right, from their standpoint, to attack the USSR. This is why we see Zelensky, and his supporters, increasingly openly flaunting Nazi associations, with the Azov Brigade, the reburial of Melnyk, the ovation for an SS veteran in the Canadian parliament a year or two ago, Boris Johnson bringing Azov Nazis to the British parliament. The bourgeoisie are saying increasingly openly that Hitler was right, and threatening us with fascism. But we must take them up on this and wage a revolutionary political struggle among the masses, who rightly hate Hitlerism, to overthrow them and the threat of Nazi barbarism they represent. There is an opportunity to do this now, because increasingly the cat is out of the bag.
