Bread, ports and barricades: Chronicle of Europe’s Autumn Spring

A spectre haunts Europe: the working class returns to the scene.

By Gregorio Carboni Maestri*

For half a century, European capitalism relied on the extraction of relative surplus value. After the exhaustion of Fordism, the monetarist turn of 1979 and the neoliberal offensive organized capitalist accumulation by dispossession: delocalisation, financialisation, the end of stable employment, and a slow proletarianisation of the middle classes. The worker was still allowed to earn on the price of goods, until, from 2008 onwards, productivity stopped growing and profit began to be sustained by the appropriation of rents, especially of workers and wage earners, by wage compression. On February 24, 2022, with the war in Ukraine, this process took a leap: wages were deindexed, “austerity” returned, and absolute surplus value became conscious politics, extracted directly from the worker’s body and life time. Peace, presented since the 19th century as a harmony of free trade, has shown itself again for what it was: an armed truce, and war has entered the very architecture of the European Union. Against this background, since October 2023, Palestine has been the catalyst for all latent struggles: university camps have set up a generation of young and not so young and opened a cycle that, passing through the tractors of the peasants of 2024 and the Serbian uprising, has not yet ended.

In these two years, the new generation that has awakened to the struggle has learned three things. That the European Union was a material accomplice in the genocide, due to its association agreements with Israel, arms trade and diplomatic silence. That the European states, led by Germany, France and the United Kingdom, proscribed solidarity with Palestine on the accusation of anti-Semitism, that is, that the rule of law was limited by criticism of Zionism. In these countries, the movement was harshly repressed by the state, with protest camps banned, students expelled from universities and the proscription of the slogan “From the river to the sea”, a strategic move by the Atlanticist bloc to prevent the convergence of those protesting against the genocide in Gaza that had already taken place in Italy and that was beginning in other countries.

The state began to demand that the institutions that were supposed to support the solidarity struggle should, on the contrary, repress it, as did prestigious universities, union confederations, right-wing, centre-left or ecologist parties. Those who saw their camp evicted, their university comrades expelled, and their slogans criminalised understood that legality is defined by the correlation of forces. This lesson would migrate to secondary schools, ports, and squares. Germany lived in parallel an invisible conflict: opposition fronts that did not converge, a sectoral unionism that won wage increases without formulating a class policy, a political camp captured by the AfD — a right-wing, nationalist, anti-war, anti-globalist party — precarious young people in the service sector and voiceless academic scholarship holders. But the repression produced the opposite of what it sought, and the generation of former lovers of the German Greens discovered in them the imperialist character of the state itself.

 Austerity and rearmament

2025 was the year of ruling class projects. The governments of the European Union designed in parallel the two moves that would later be fought in the streets: the cut in social spending and rearmament. On January 31, in Belgium, five parties (the N-VA, the MR, Les Engagés, the CD&V and the Flemish socialists of Vooruit) signed the government agreement that the press called the Arizona Coalition, due to the colours of the associated parties and those of the flag of the US state of Arizona. The government was led by Bart De Wever, a Flemish separatist nationalist of the extreme right. Its program was the most coherent in Western Europe, from the point of view of the ruling classes. With a public deficit of over 5%, it prepared an adjustment of about 10 billion euros. The pension bill, approved on May 28, 2026, introduced a penalty of 5% for each year of early retirement before the age of 67, starting in 2027; required 156 days worked to count one year for early retirements; dismantled the retirement of civil servants; raised the right to end-of-career employment, that is, working fewer hours, from 25 to 35 years of contribution; suppressed pre-retirements, disregarding arduous work, as if it were the same to spend thirty years in an office or lifting bricks on a construction site; determined during the entire legislature, no increase for the lowest pensions; and predicted 2.4 billion euros of savings in four years. The automatic indexation of wages, a historic achievement of the Belgian working class, would not function, from 2026 to 2028, for salaries above 4,000 euros gross: it started at the top, but it was known that, by the same principle, the same would be done with the lowest wages. In addition, an increase in Value Added Tax, later shelved, and the annual bank of hours worked was announced. The unions limited themselves to filing an appeal with the Constitutional Court, which would rule in mid-2028, when the ‘reform’ would already have been applied. While cutting pensions, the country increased its military spending by 59%.

In March, the European Commission presented the Rearm Europe plan, renamed Readiness 2030 when the first name seemed too blatant: 800 billion euros for defence over five years. In June, in The Hague, NATO set a target of 5% of GDP for 2035, 3.5% in defence and up to 1.5% in “enhanced security”. The “Escape from the Stability Pact” clause, which allows member states to temporarily flout the draconian budget limits dictated by the European Union, was triggered for arms spending. When it comes to weapons, money appears. When it comes to pensions, it disappears! Maintaining these budgets required cutting social spending, limiting health and postponing all non-military public investment. Friedrich Merz, the least popular chancellor in Germany’s recent history, announced that he wanted “the strongest army in Europe.” At the end of the year, the European Union’s military spending was close to 400 billion. It was a rearmament undertaken when the United States could not cede more autonomy to Europe, which must continue to be a semi-vassal protectorate, increasingly dependent on a declining empire. And 78% of European defence purchases are and should be made mainly in the United States. The European Union and the Atlantic Alliance, Washington’s strategic annex, would be a semi-periphery dependent on tourism and foreign capital, with the “war economy” as the only viable and quick alternative to reassure European capital.

On September 10, 2025, the subjugated population of the moribund Franco-German axis began to raise their heads and go to fight, launching the slogan that would travel the continent considered to be the exclusive property of the ruling classes: “Let’s block everything”. That is, to physically stop France and Germany, in opposition to austerity policies. And the initially student mobilizations took to the streets, as a memory and legacy of the Yellow Vests, of the demonstrations of workers and popular sectors of 2018. They were faced with two divergent paths: a general strike or the encapsulation of the movement in the 2027 elections. The day against the budget of Bayrou, the French prime minister, was repeated on September 18, 2025.

 Italy: the centrality of the working class

In Italy, on September 22, 2025, the rank-and-file unions called for a national strike with a port and rail stoppage, and in Genoa, access to the port was blocked. On October 3, after the approach of the Freedom Flotilla that tried to break the siege of Gaza, the CGIL, the Italian General Confederation of Labor, the seventh largest union in the world by number of members, and the USB, the Marxist Grassroots Trade Union Union, jointly called for a general strike for Palestine. Since 1968, it was the first time that a large mass federation paralyzed a European country for an anti-imperialist issue. The separation between the “social” and the “political”, which the CGIL, conservative and socio-liberal, had scrupulously respected since 1945, reserving the “social” and leaving the “political” to the parties, broke down that day. There were condensed the new political-ideological contents of the future “spring in autumn”.

The international silence of the press and the left on the scale of the Italian struggle was proportional to the fear that the ruling classes were beginning to feel in the face of what was happening in a country where Giorgia Meloni, in the recent neo- or post-fascist past, as you like, at the head of the government, unlike her colleagues in the “cordon sanitaire” of the European Union, could not even prohibit pro-Palestinian demonstrations or symbols, as Germany or France did. The street was as free in the country “governed by the post-fascist” as in the Spain of the PSOE, and RAI, the powerful Italian public television, a political battleground, did not admit the linear globalist propaganda of German public television. It has been proven that a strong, organized and legitimate mass movement does not allow itself to be blocked even under extreme right-wing governments. In Italy, the normal accusations, in the rest of Europe, of liberal politicians or claiming to be left-wing against the pro-Palestinian movement, would be accused of… fascism.

German paradox

The strongest paradox was produced in Germany, where thousands of left-wing citizens demonstrated every Saturday against the danger of the Alternative for Germany (AfD), presented as a true pro-fascist Black Wolf, by the entire ruling class. This while the country lives under the harsh systematic repression and censorship of any pacifist movement against the massacre in Gaza or for an end to the conflict in Ukraine, by the governing parties, Greens, CDU, SPD, which are part of the “cordon sanitaire” of the European Union.

In France, Emmanuel Macron’s party has occupied the Elysée since May 2017, thanks to two electoral victories allowed by the votes of the left, on the right, in the second round, against the “extreme right”, seduced by the narrative of the “politics of the least evil”. This when Macronism continued to serve, without any moderation, the interests of big capital, and repressed the popular movements that guaranteed it the election. In this context, the French National Assembly debated legislative proposals to equate anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism, and thus punish it. On October 10, 2025, after Macron reorganized the Executive and reinvested Sébastien Lecornu as prime minister of a minority government, the institutional instability of a country where, since 2017, the longevity of ministerial portfolios has been drastically reduced to less than a year became visible again.

The next day, October 11, a ceasefire came into force in Gaza that soon proved to be fictitious, as Israeli forces claimed more than 1,460 additional lives after the agreement. This brought the total death toll to more than 74,200 people since the resumption of the conflict in 2023, while Israel kept about 60% of Gaza’s territory under military control. Faced with the de facto continuity of the military actions by the Israelis, the cycle of social and political mobilization continued. At the end of the year, the Bundestag, the German parliament, approved the law on military service: from July 2027, medical and military fitness exams would be mandatory for those born after 2008. Rearming meant, after all, recruiting. Therefore, the Bundeswehr, the German armed forces, called up the meager thousand young people who agreed to enlist. On December 11, the war economy provoked, in Portugal, the first joint general strike of the CGTP and the UGT, since 2013, called against the government’s “labour package”. At the end of the year, the cauldron was prepared. It was enough to set it on fire.

2026: war has arrived by the gas bill

The detonator was called Hormuz, a strait of warm waters that would reduce Europe to cold. As four years earlier, war would enter every home in Europe by the gas bill. But first, in February 2026, two European governments began to feel the temper of the new political era. On the 2nd, in Germany, the powerful United Service Union (Ver.di) called a national warning day, paralyzing public transport, followed by successive strikes by the train drivers of the German Union of Locomotive Drivers (GDL), the last stable worker sector of the German export model. On the 20th, in France, Europe’s second power, Prime Minister Lecornu approved the 2026 budget law without submitting it to a vote in Parliament, following the pattern desired by globalism for the European Union – budgets without parliament.

On February 28, the United States and Israel illegally attacked Iran, without declaring war. Liquefied natural gas traffic through the strait was interrupted. That same day, in Portugal, thousands of people demonstrated against the labour package; no one yet knew that the war in the East would also influence that dispute. On March 2, an isolated, overburdened Macron without a majority announced an increase in the French nuclear arsenal that his country did not know how to pay for. Brent — crude oil with a reference price in the negotiations — rose to 80 or 82 dollars a barrel that month; in October, it would reach 110 before falling ten dollars.

Since the start of the war, the price of gas has risen by 140%. European natural gas deposits fell by an average of 74%, the lowest level since 2011, and in September storage was at 67%, compared to the usual 80% for that season. The war between the US and Israel added some 106 billion euros to the continent’s energy bill. Inflation reached 3.8%. Diesel fuel would have risen by 45% or more. In Germany, fuel prices rose by 49% and heating oil by 92% – a family that was heating itself with it started paying almost twice as much as a year earlier. Austria, Spain, Italy and Croatia reduced fuel taxes in September and October, without further results. Expensive energy made chemicals, steel and fertilizers, industry, work and food more expensive. The war thus entered every home, with the electricity bill, with the price of bread, with the amount paid for car fuel. For the European working and popular classes, the war against Iran would result in a costlier and colder winter.

It’s Capitalism, Stupid!

The first warning of what diesel fuel could do came from Ireland. Between April 7 and 14, convoys of tractors and trucks blocked the roads protesting the price of fuel — the government approved a package of 505 million euros and a secretary of state resigned. In May, in the other extreme periphery of Europe, Albania, the “flamingo revolution” was born. It began as a protest against a luxury tourist complex linked to investors associated with Jared Kushner and Ivanka Trump, near Zvërnec, in an environmentally protected area of the Albanian coast. In a few months, the opposition movement became, with the student protests in Serbia, the most radical political revolt in the Balkans in recent years.

To understand the Albanian opposition, it is necessary to know the regime of Edi Rama, the spoiled boy of the West, in power since 2013: a coastline handed over to Turkish and European capital; a subsoil gifted to energy multinationals, services dependent on Italian capital; a capital designed by the great globalist architects; a puppet state behind a democratic façade; a promise of European membership always postponed and a youth, without a future, leaving the country. Albania, with 2.9 million inhabitants in 2008, had 2.7 million in 2024. In June, another election with accusations of fraud expanded the popular protest and crossed it with the institutional opposition. It was a horizontal revolt, without formal direction, coordinated by WhatsApp, Telegram and Snapchat, with a base that expanded from the students and, for this very reason, without a strategic horizon: spontaneity without organization, indignation without program, iconography without theory. The Atlanticist analysts asked the poorly formulated question: “Who is behind the movement?” Behind the enormous popular disgust there was only… capitalism, stupid!

The struggle expands and they are confused

On May 22, German students demonstrated in Berlin against war, rearmament and austerity. They were not necessarily the same people who had seen the Berlin regime violently ban their camps and their pro-Palestinian slogans. In many cases, they voted for the AfD and the Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance — an anti-globalist, anti-militarist, anti-savage immigration left-wing political group that splintered from the Left Party (Die Linke). The opposition fronts were expanding and confusing throughout Europe. On June 3, the CGTP again paralyzed Portugal.

On the 4th and 5th, the Parliament of the Wallonia-Brussels Federation, a region of federalized Belgium, approved, after fourteen hours of debate, the decree-program for education: two more school terms to be completed by secondary teachers, an increase in enrollment and cuts in school budgets. The icing on the cake was a 3,100% increase in the price of the public transport pass for young people.

On 19 June, the Portuguese Assembly of the Republic rejected the labour bill under discussion in its entirety, in the first major victory of the opposition wave. On 3 July, the European Commission proposed five “projects of common interest” in terms of armaments. The European Union’s military spending grew that year by about 80 billion more, reaching 2.5% of gross domestic product. On the 8th, Belgian teachers gathered in front of the Parliament in Brussels with a slogan that summed up the summer and pointed to the Minister of Education, Valérie Glatigny: “Glatigny démission [Glatigny resign]”.

 September 2026: German ballot boxes and schools spark earthquake

If, in recent years, popular movements struggled not to lose what they had and did not identify with the programs of the institutional parties, it was enough to say “it’s capitalism, stupid” and no one would know very well what came next. In September, something different began to be seen: following the impulse of the street, European political formations collected proposals belonging to the forbidden territory of pamphlets and political rallies. If energy was expensive due to war and speculation, it was necessary to demand military neutrality and exit from NATO. If housing was expensive, it should pass to public control. And the large companies that were making huge profits at the expense of the crisis had to be nationalized under the control of their workers and users. And words like “nationalize” or “abandon the Atlantic pact”, which, until then, had not reached the public debate or if they did, were unsuccessful, now began to yield overwhelming electoral victories.

In September, Germany was the most eloquent example of this electoral tsunami, both for the populist, nationalist, anti-globalist right and for the left. On September 6, the first unprecedented Teutonic shift of the electoral boards occurred in the regional election in Saxony-Anhalt, with the AfD collecting 43.8% of the vote, thirty-nine seats out of eighty-three, while the CDU — the great party of capital and the globalist right — retreated. On September 20, the second earthquake of this spring occurred in the autumn with the German electoral map breaking up in just one day. In Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, in the former East Germany, the AfD won 38.2% compared to 35.5% for the SPD, the historic German social democracy, then in the governing coalition, generally the first force in other regions of the deindustrialized east. In both Saxony-Anhalt and Mecklenburg, the program that led to the victory of the nationalist, populist, anti-globalist right called for an end to the war economy, the suspension of all military aid to Kiev, the repair of Nord Stream to resume refuelling with Russian gas, the lifting of all sanctions on Moscow and the veto of Ukraine’s entry into NATO and the European Union.

The European media and globalist parties ignored these demands and focused their attention on reactionary proposals, such as replacing social assistance with workfare, closing the borders to asylum seekers, abolishing the public radio and television tax and dismantling the Green Deal. They tried not to talk about the coming war with the Russian Federation that they propose, with a date set for 2030, preferring to scare the population with the “return of fascism”. In the German capital, on the same election days, the post-communists of Die Linke – The Left – reaped the best result in their history since the fall of the wall: 25.7% and forty-five seats, with a participation of 74.2% of the electorate, while the SPD touched its historic low and the AfD stood at 16.3%. They advocated expropriating and nationalizing 220,000 properties in the hands of real estate multinationals, establishing a universal transport pass at nine euros and suppressing school evaluations for children up to the ninth grade. And once again, the media and globalist parties began to denounce the alleged “anti-Semitism” of the former communists, who denounce the Zionist genocide, and tried to horrify the population with that party’s proposal to “nationalize”, pronounced due to the “return of the reds”.

 Soaking the beards

Prevention is better than cure. The Italian Euro-Atlanticist ruling class prepared to make it difficult for future minority alternatives born of this explosive social context to enter the political system, approving in the Senate an electoral law amendment, which would drastically raise the requirements for new political formations without parliamentary representation to be able to run in elections. The number of signatures required per electoral district increased from 1,500 to 9,000 physical signatures, maintaining the exemptions from collecting signatures only for those forces that already had parliamentarians. The measure provoked a broad debate and was described by analysts as a “lock clause”. The text began its processing in the Chamber of Deputies, where it faced the predictable requests for revision on the “use of the digital signature” by the social democratic left, which specialized in demanding only the “relief of the slaves’ chains”, and objections of unconstitutionality on the part of the almost non-existent class opposition in parliament.

On September 24, in Germany, some 45,000 students from more than eighty cities staged their fourth school strike against military service. They had understood the arithmetic: the money for the tanks was what was lacking in their rickety schools, and the soldiers of these tanks, who would return from the war without legs, would be them. Two days later, on the 26th of the same month, the DGB, the confederation of German trade unions, and IG Metall, historically linked to co-management, were forced by the rank and file to mobilize throughout the month against Chancellor Merz’s program of cuts and the biggest plans to close Volkswagen, Mercedes, Audi and BMW since 1945. On the streets, students joined the workers’ demonstrations. The protest against conscription was united with the criticism of rearmament and austerity. It was the first worker-student rapprochement of the autumn, and the Atlanticist press preferred not to call the movement that broke through the mirage of German capitalist stability “spring.”

On that same September 26, in Madrid, the first tent was erected in the Puerta del Sol. In a few days there were hundreds. The camp was heir to the “indignados movement” against unemployment, low wages, high rents and so on, from May 15, 2011, also known as the 15-M movement. The camp in Puerta del Sol was born from the gap between rents that had risen by 29% while wages were advancing by 7.4%. A movement that was embodied by Maricarmen Abascal, an 87-year-old evicted from her Madrid home because of an increase in rent that she could not pay. The old lady died a few days after returning to her home, in the midst of the movement. In France, secondary schools were once again occupied. The high school movement, convened by the Union of Secondary Students, with the support of the Student Union, mobilized against a 2027 budget that abolished 4,500 civil service positions, and against the chronic lack of teachers, crowded classrooms, the precariousness of the teaching staff, the ‘reforms’ of the baccalaureate and elitist modifications to the rules of university enrolment (Parcoursup reform). In Belgium, French-speaking students looking across the border, ended up crossing it on October 1.

 Spring in Autumn

In October 2026, in Belgium, the mobilizations of secondary schools brought spring air to the middle of autumn. On the 1st, without a centralized convocation, thousands of high school students blocked a dozen schools in Liège. In a few days, the movement travelled throughout Wallonia, the French-speaking region of Belgium, and reached Brussels, taking the form of blockades and assemblies arriving from France, where, on that day, the high school movement totalled more than 900 initiatives. Soon, the school issue was associated, in Spain, with the issue of housing. On the 2nd, the Spanish congress rejected the government’s decrees in favour of the democratization of housing, delegitimizing itself as a space for mediation. On the 3rd, demonstrations were held in fifty cities, with half a million demonstrators in Madrid alone. The Tenants’ Union shouted loudly what was already known – housing was the mechanism by which land rent appropriates wages. The forces of repression responded harshly and a ‘deterrent’ grenadetore off the hand of a young man in Lens. On the 9th, the FGTB, Belgium’s large French-speaking workers’ union, held the first major Union Day in Brussels at the multi-class station, which paralyzed transport on the same day that in Taranto, in southern Italy, Europe’s largest steelmaker, announced the closure of its blast furnaces. And on the 10th, as the urban middle class marched for the climate on the eve of COP31, Israeli drones continued to kill in Gaza, on the eve of the anniversary of a farcical ceasefire.

On Sunday the 11th, at ten o’clock in the evening, when the cities were already asleep, another railway strike began in Belgium. And meanwhile, in Lisbon and Porto, whose rents had risen by 124% since 2015, tens of thousands of people marched for the right to housing and against the law that facilitated evictions, camping in the heart of those cities, in a vigil under the windows of the houses they could not inhabit, until the police evicted them. So critical and of all was the hour, that even the one who felt, among all, as the most powerful, had to suffer it. Trump: frightened by the catastrophic polls that would be carried out and by the palpable dissatisfaction of the US working class with the MAGA base, which felt betrayed by the promise of peace and falling prices, seeking to make fuel cheaper before the midterm elections on November 3, announced an agreement to buy diesel fuel from Moscow, lifting sanctions on Russian hydrocarbons and throwing neoconservatives and globalists into panic. Which was of no use to him. And he declared to journalists, as if dropping a stone into a well to measure by the echo how deep his abyss was, that a change of leadership in Ukraine was needed. Meanwhile, London, the European Union and the neoconservatives, and with them the US Democratic Party, boycotted Putin’s outstretched hand: they made it known that they were preparing to send troops to Ukraine, while the head of the British armed forces warned the British “citizens” of the sacrifices they would have to face for the “security of the Fatherland”, a word that, spoken from above, always cries out for the blood to be shed by those below.

In the south of Italy, a crucial moment of the movement began. Truck drivers and farmers blocked the tolls on the Apulian and Campania motorways against diesel fuel that was 35% more expensive. In a few days, transport came to a standstill in Sicily and Calabria. And they were joined by fishermen, bakers and ambulance drivers. With the lack of fuel, the supermarkets in the Italian meridian began to empty out. And solidarity with the movement came from all sides. The European press barely reported what had happened and a good part of the postmodern left looked at it with suspicion, because it came from provincial sectors suspected of voting for Meloni. On the 12th, the metallurgical unions stopped twenty-four hours at the gigantic Siderúrgica de Italia, in Taranto, in the extreme south of Italy. By occupying state road 106, they left three regions without fuel. To extinguish the blast furnaces of the Ionian Sea, with European steel paying for the most expensive energy in the world, was to open the market to global steel, to demand public subsidies in the name of the “green transition” and the reduction of pollution. On the same day, the Public Services Trade Union Confederation (CGSP) stopped Belgian public services. In Italy, with the extension of the strike, workers occupied the city hall of Genoa and in Paris, the demonstration of the 5th brought together hundreds of thousands of demonstrators, taking to the streets the proposal for a general strike, while in Tirana, the capital of Albania, students tried to break into the Ministry of Education. On the 14th, the CGIL stopped Tuscany and the European Commission admitted that the winter would be “very, very difficult”. And the fire came: on the 15th and 16th, with hundreds of secondary schools occupied in Italy, the uprising, which spread throughout Albania, promoted a “No Meloni Day” of disturbances, with hundreds of arrests, mostly of minors. In Taranto, the trade union confederations agreed to a tactical truce, criticized by the rank and file. In Tirana, Edi Rama, prime minister of Albania since September 2013, attributed the protests to “foreign hands”.

The big day

Saturday, October 17, was the great day of the movement. In France, the march against the high cost of living brought together some 675,000 people. There was looting and arson in several cities: more than 2,000 arrested, hundreds of police injured, thousands of businesses damaged. In Limoges, the Gothic and eclectic municipal palace of 1883 burned down, which deeply divided opinions, including those who supported the mobilisations. The government took the opportunity to decree localized curfews for minors and to deploy police and military personnel to guard urban property. In Brussels, the demonstration ended in clashes in front of the Stock Exchange, with about two hundred arrested between Brussels and Liège, among them twenty-five minors, with barricades at the Midi station and disturbances in the Marolles. Bernard Quintin, Belgium’s Minister of the Interior, called the events “pure and simple” violence, in a country where, since 2012, there have been 120 deaths due to police interventions or in the custody of the so-called forces of order.

That same Saturday, in Taybeh, Palestine,  masked Israeli settlers attacked and destroyed the car of a convoy of French and Polish diplomats, including the Belgian consul general in Jerusalem. This was not reported by the mainstream press, since it had its eyes fixed on the broken windows of Starbucks and McDonald’s. On the contrary, there was much talk, in a euphoric and warmongering tone, of the attack by 1,015 drones from Ukraine and NATO territories against the Leningrad region. A map published by the Ukrainian media revealed the direct involvement of Estonia, Latvia and Finland in the attack. Drones attacked oil terminals to block the plan to sell diesel fuel to the US, and VK’s data centre, the Russian Facebook, leaving twenty thousand people without electricity and forcing the closure of Pulkovo airport. Among the targets were also the Ruchyí warehouse, the Kolpin warehouses and Ozon’s logistics. Trump, exasperated, publicly ordered Ukraine to stop attacks on diesel fuel infrastructure and unilaterally declared a ceasefire on energy infrastructure, disobeyed by Volodymyr Zelensky who denounced the interruption of information provided by the US and the cut of Elon Musk’s Starlink service.

In Rome, the CGIL brought about a hundred thousand demonstrators to the streets. On the weekend of October 18 and 19, Milan witnessed scenes of unexpected violence in the Italian context, with minors and young people involved in a kind of unarmed urban guerrilla war in Piazza Duomo with the police forces “overflowing”. Lia Quartapelle, a militant of the Democratic Party, formerly the Italian Communist Party, converted to social-democratic liberalism, was the first to speak of “foreign powers” amplifying demonstrations called by social networks. President Mattarella, also of the PD, spoke of “violence exploited in an unexpected way by unprecedented subjects…”, demanding a deeper analysis of the events. Guido Crosetto, Minister of Defense, in response to his colleague Matteo Salvini, of the League, a right-wing and populist movement, said that it was useless to call in more soldiers if they could not act as police. It was “a hybrid war that someone is waging against our nations with unconventional instruments called TikTok, social networks, YouTube. The West must react.” Zelensky, the Ukrainian president with an indefinite term, doubled down: “Russia has been waging a hybrid war against Europe for a long time, also against Italy, France, the United Kingdom and Germany, through television, the media, the internet and networks. Citizens must not allow themselves to be manipulated by Russian campaigns.” Stefania Craxi, from Berlusconi’s party, now deceased, spoke of orchestrated disinformation. And Salvini, with known xenophobia, disavowed the neoconservative faction of his government allies, saying that they should point elsewhere: “I read strange things, the Russians…”; “I am worried about the Islamic invasion, not hybrid war.” And while so many were naming an invisible enemy, in Cosenza, Calabria, in southern Italy, the “Bread Revolt” began, the oldest of the names of hunger: 870 bakers closed their establishments against the increase in the price of raw materials and the pressure of large distributors. Thirty-one baker artisans camped on state 106 with the truck drivers, denouncing that flour had risen by one euro for every ten kilos and gas by 0.70 per litre.

 “Putin’s hand”

Throughout Europe, rulers and the mainstream media attributed the protests to the “Russian hand” and focused the news and criticism on the youth and lumpen riots of the peripheries, the broken windows and the looting of luxury brand stores. They tried to fuel hatred against the demonstrators and silence the inter-class demands supported by the majority of the population crushed by the crisis. In Tirana, on the fifth day of revolt, the Supreme Court burned; Rama ruled out resigning, but on the 19th, thousands of demonstrators demanded his departure and 141 university professors condemned police violence. In Italy, the Ministry of the Interior announced that the intelligence services and the anti-terrorist police would investigate the announced strikes.

On the 20th, in Milan, Matteo Salvini received all the transport unions and the government put on the table 480 million euros against the increase in fuel prices and promised a “phase 2”, of aid, for the 27th. Fedralog, an association of companies in the freight transport, logistics and distribution sector, declared itself “not satisfied” after the meeting. In Sicily, the strike was lifted, maintaining the state of unrest, while Puglia, Calabria and Campania maintained the suspensions of services, blockades and demonstrations, especially active in the small towns of Foggia, Poggio Imperiale and San Severo. In front of Puglia, on the other side of the Adriatic, in Tirana, demonstrators placed empty chairs in front of the prime minister’s headquarters, offering a seat for a dialogue that was not coming, and photographs of bare hands leaning on police shields, the gesture of those who show that they do not carry weapons, went around the world. The official balance already spoke of 500 arrested and 310 injured, 191 of them policemen, while Rama accused the demonstrators of “crossing the red line” and threatening the country’s accession to the European Union. He proposed, me or chaos. In Paris, while Prime Minister Lecornu received the unions, Laurent Nuñez, Minister of the Interior, asked the mayors to ban the demonstrations on Saturday 24 that did not guarantee order, a measure immediately applied by the mayors of Rouen, Le Havre, Toulon and Perpignan, while the central government deployed military personnel from the “Sentinelle” operation, that is, military personnel spread across France, since 2015, to prevent terrorist attacks. In Brussels, anonymous calls were circulated for the date of the demonstration, while in Portugal, in the middle of the week, a protest for housing ended with 55 arrests.

In Italy, the failure of the agreement with the transporters interrupted the supply of fresh food, from milk to fruit and vegetables, and more than a hundred thousand demonstrators joined the day of strikes and protests that began to register the distance between the bureaucracy of the trade union confederations and the base of the movement, focused on October 30. Meanwhile, Brent crude touched 110 dollars. On the 22nd, the important university campus of Solbosch, in Belgium, was occupied again, with the protest of the transporters still active, while from Budapest to Riga, the capital of Latvia, the governments looked uneasily at the calendar. On Saturday, October 24, in France, the day of mobilization took place despite the government ban in several cities and with the army on the street. Macron asked for what the presidents ask when they no longer know what to ask of the so-called forces of order: “firmness”. In Rome, the “Italy Out of War” demonstration challenged the Russophobic alarmist narratives of the government and traveled through the central Via Cavour. The slogan that was heard the most was the demand for the interruption of all complicity in the Palestinian genocide and in the aggression against Russia and Iran. That public resources be invested in schools, health, services and territory, and not in ruins and destruction. The demonstrators commonly carried, as in the marches of the left, the flags of Cuba, Lebanon, Palestine and Iran. They also carried with them the Italian standard, in the official version, or in the variant of the communist Garibaldi Brigades of the war of resistance against Nazi-fascism, in general, a red star on the white background of the Italian tricolor, proposed as the flag of the future peninsular socialist society. With it, it was recalled that the countries of Europe must also resist imperialist interference. In order not to be totally overtaken by the movement that took to the streets, University Action, an extreme right-wing student organization, part of the fascistic Roman student associations where Meloni was politically trained, called for its own demonstration. It complained about the price of textbooks, university bureaucracy, fraud in income indicators (ISEE) and scholarships, and demanded more sports and more civic education. In Brussels, an anonymous summons scheduled the meeting for the demonstration in the city center and announced how it would act during the protest, its way of confirming its presence at the event.

The Students’ List

In the former Yugoslavia, the elections in Serbia gave a historic victory to the “Students’ List”. Vucic, the outgoing president, after fourteen years in power, commented on his defeat, once again spoke of a “colour revolution” supported by the European Union. The reality was different. The list, formed from the bottom up and despite the pressures of the ruling apparatus, had little in common with the pro-Western liberal agenda. Among its members were patriots and friends of the Slavic world, for whom fraternity weighed more than subsidies from Amnesty or European funds. The program of the list proposed “preserving the traditional association with the Russian Federation, maintaining the refusal to impose sanctions” and the “refusal of the agreements with Pristina signed by Vucic in Brussels”, concerning the recognition of the Kosovar authorities. Accession to the European Union was defined as “non-priority”.

On the 27th, two signs made it clear to what extent the ruling classes were beginning to feel the pressure of the masses. The first: the Italian government was forced to open a negotiating table on steel at the seat of government, in front of Marcus Aurelius’ column in Rome, while Salvini opened a discussion with the transporters. The second, more than 2,000 kilometers from Rome, was then practically unthinkable: Alexander Stubb, president of Finland, a country where unemployment is around 12%, and Jonas Gahr Støre, prime minister of Norway, called Vladimir Putin from Helsinki to talk about negotiations, asking him to meet with Zelensky and put an end to the special military operation. The call, made at the initiative of the Nordics, lasted ninety minutes: more time than the European governments had dedicated in three years to talking to Moscow. A few days later, on the 29th, the European Union’s energy ministers discussed common measures to reduce consumption, fearing that the Hormuz crisis would last for months. At nine in the evening, the Italian railways and motorways stopped: the historic strike the next day began.

On October 30, the rank-and-file unions (USB, CUB, USI-CIT and the Cobas) paralyzed Italy for twenty-four hours, hitting the public sector, industry, services, trains, planes, taxis and motorways. The strike was against the famine, the war and military spending, which, in terms of the Italian contribution alone, was estimated at around 20 billion since 2021. The sources differed on whether the stoppage affected the entire transport sector. What left no room for doubt was the position of the Guarantee Commission. This public body for monitoring compliance with the legislation on strikes had declared that the call violated the rules due to the proximity of All Souls’ Day, celebrated on November 2 in Italy, and the proximity of two strikes in the same sector. Like a police officer who applies the fine even before the car starts, the state was preparing to outlaw the strike before it began.

 Everyone standing still

On the same day, in addition, more than forty ports, from the Cantabrian to the Mediterranean, closed in protest against the transport of weapons to conflict zones, rearmament, the war economy, the militarization of port infrastructures and genocide in Palestine. The mobilization was part of a worldwide strike of dockers in twenty-two countries, coordinated by the Ports in Action network and followed in Marseille, Le Havre, Dunkirk, Bordeaux, Patras, Thessaloniki, Genoa, Trieste, Livorno, Gioia Tauro, Ancona, Civitavecchia, Carrara, Bari, Barcelona, Valencia, Bilbao, Hamburg, Tangier, Casablanca, Istanbul, Mersin, Bombay, Chennai, Oakland, San Francisco, Dublin, Cork and in more than a hundred ports. In Athens, Giorgos Gogos, president of the Piraeus dockers’ union, denounced the transformation of ports into logistics platforms at the service of war, under a clear slogan: “Ports must serve peoples, not wars. We do not carry death.” In Ravenna, in Emilia-Romagna, the procession left at nine o’clock from Piazza del Popolo towards the port on the Adriatic Sea. Farmers’ tractors and trucks headed for Rome. It was the first time that internationalist solidarity ceased to be just a declaration and became a force for economic interruption, intervening directly in the circulation of capital and military transport. It is one thing to sign a manifesto, but quite another not to unload the ship.

The Italian strike, historic for its national participation and connection with the world day of port stoppage, was a qualitative leap. It created an objective basis that allowed the alliance between the industrial proletariat, peasants, students and small owners, as well as the development of a comprehensive political consciousness about war, anti-imperialism, the economic crisis and the criminal character of the capitalist system. The mobilization united inhabitants of the cities and the interior, old and young, reaching the most diverse sectors of society and articulating the complexity of their demands in a way that is incomparable to other recent moments. The demonstrations were multitudinous, with millions of citizens in the streets of the metropolises, large, medium and small cities, and even the villages.

Thus ended the month of October, and what some journalists baptized, amid bewilderment and alarm, the “European Spring” was in reality the late ripening of a cycle. Spring arrived in the autumn because the contradiction took years to find its mass expression: to move from moral solidarity with Palestine to material solidarity, from the university camp to the general strike. No one wrote this autumn’s calendar: it was written by force of things, and so when it was written, no committee, no chancellery, and no editorial staff could modify it. While the indexation of salaries or spending on education was denied, billions were destined for rearmament and the military alliance with Israel and the United States against Iran and Palestine. And, of course, for a corrupt and undemocratic Ukrainian government.

 Billions to Death

As of February 2022, according to the European Commission’s documentation updated in mid-October, the European Union had directly disbursed around €117 billion in support for Ukraine: €43.9 billion in assistance under the Ukraine Facility, €43.3 billion for urgent needs on the ground, €19.8 billion under the Ukraine Support Loan (including €15.8 billion in military aid), €2.8 billion in loans and guarantees from the EIB, the EBRD and other financial institutions guaranteed by the EU, €1.2 billion in bilateral cooperation, €4.5 billion in other forms of support and only 1.19% of the total, or €1.4 billion, in humanitarian aid. For people, rounding up. In the Donbass alone, where Italian military and Wehrmacht troops had already passed through in 1941, there have been 13,500 civilian casualties and 25,000 wounded since 2014; In border regions, since 2022, there have been two thousand deaths and five thousand injured, including 480 children killed and 2,153 injured.

These contradictions undermined the budgetary legitimacy of governments. Which is a more elaborate way of saying that people no longer believe in their numbers. The war also provided a militant infrastructure: the camps, committees, and legal defence networks built over three years were also used in struggles for housing, education, and strikes, just as chairs from a funeral are kept to be used again on a birthday. The continuity of the actions of young militants between the 2024 encampments and the 2026 demonstrations was the organizing piece of this cycle. This process introduced the category of imperialism into everyday life: the degradation of public services came to be interpreted as a consequence of the Atlanticist state of war, an explanation that, in a nutshell, related the war to the lack of doctors, the interruption of trains, and the increase in the cost of housing. And it had, finally, two geopolitical effects. It deepened the Atlantic fracture, because the inability of the European Union to formulate an autonomous position delegitimized it in the eyes of its youth, who have a short memory for speeches and a long memory for bills. And it brought the multipolar world to the foreground: the mobilized generation discovered that South Africa, Brazil, Turkey, Iran and China had held more advanced positions on Palestine than the European Union and, with this discovery, their political consciousness was no longer centred on Europe.

But if none of the above can be understood without the war, the war explains the moment and not the whole movement. To understand why a student from Wrocław, a truck driver from Abruzzo, a tenant from Stuttgart, a dockworker from Algeciras and a student from Rotterdam did in the same month what they had not done in years, other elements of explanation are needed, in addition to energy bills, housing, school and recruitment: the wars (West-vs-Palestine, West-vs-Russia, West-vs-Iran) contributed to unleashing all these mobilizations at the same time. Wars and Russophobia are already a structural part of the ideological architecture of the EU. At the end of October, when it became known that Trump and Russia were discussing reactivating gas supplies after the war, including through Nord Stream and with US investors included, Brussels replied that the pipeline would not come into operation even in the event of peace. Commission spokeswoman Paula Pinho said that the Union was opposed to the attempt to reactivate it. There was even a law in front of it that prohibited importing gas from Russia regardless of what happened. Anna-Kaisa Itkonen, the European Union’s representative for energy, explained it with the calm of someone who lives on another planet: the renunciation of Russian gas was sanctioned within the framework of the REPowerEU plan and did not depend on sanctions or agreements. Long-term contracts for LNG and gas pipelines would expire in 2027. Itkonen did not say what Europeans would eat when bread, which had accumulated an average increase of 25% in the Union since 2022, continued to rise. Nor  did he propose croissants. Marie Antoinette, at least, had a proposal. And bread, precisely, was talked about in Cosenza, Calabria, where bakery associations were regrettably announcing the entry into force of the new minimum price: from 3 to 3.80 euros per kilo, 26.7% more.

 The Lame Duck

This spring in the fall, and the historic defeat of the Republicans in the November 3 midterm elections in the US, the worst since Watergate, inflicted with the support of a MAGA working class betrayed by Trump’s promises, will increase the pressure on an already retreating president to obtain concrete results in the trilateral negotiations with Russia and Ukraine scheduled in Abu Dhabi sometime in November. And they will confirm the isolation and historical irrelevance of the Europeans, who will not be able to participate under any circumstances. Or, as the Russian president’s advisor, Yuri Ushakov, sarcastically explained: “they can participate if they buy tickets, but no one thinks of inviting them to the negotiating table.” This, after former German Chancellor Angela Merkel, one of the main responsible for this geopolitical disaster, had declared that “Europe must participate in the negotiating process.” Participate, they will participate: from an audience. Meanwhile, with the return of the Democrats, the EU, the globalists and the anti-patriarchal warmongers, reinvigorated, are getting ready for the “wilful” manoeuvres planned for November in Poland to simulate a displacement on Ukrainian territory.

After the results of the midterm elections, financial markets suffered a sudden and accelerated fall, motivated by the fear of possible regulations or bans on advanced artificial intelligence promoted by members of Congress. In the early hours of the day, there were massive sales that caused double-digit falls in important companies such as Tesla, Nvidia, AMD or Micron, while volatility soared and investors called, seized by panic, their stockbrokers on Wall Street. As the day progressed, the volume of the fall erased the high recorded after the elections and wiped out billions of dollars in market capitalisation in a few minutes, while political instability deepened after management layoffs were confirmed. In the midst of the debacle, positions in the financial sector and the data industry ended up being divided between those who defended the continued growth of the technology sector, a very important element in recent campaigns, and analysts who maintained that this fall marked the beginning of the definitive collapse of the artificial intelligence bubble.

On November 5, the CGT interprofessional general strike brought together more than one and a half million demonstrators in France, according to union estimates; Raphaël Glucksmann, the candidate of the Socialist Party, was booed and expelled from the procession. In Marseille, 350 musicians and thousands of demonstrators sang the Internationale, “Bella ciao” and other struggle songs, a tradition increasingly rooted in European demonstrations. For the 11th, the strike of CCOO and UGT is called in Spain, which will be the first general strike in fourteen years, an organized stoppage of production born from the 2026 Sol camp, that is, a leap in quality that will measure the maturity of the cycle. For the week of the 23rd, Belgium, a new strike with the FGTB, if the government changes the indexation. In Italy, where all the fronts (steel, trucks, countryside, secondary schools, national strike) have converged, the union fracture is accelerating: the confederal leadership of the CGIL, pressured by the rank and file, called for the strike they demanded, but a month later, for November 20, and with the horizon tamed, while the rank-and-file unions reorganize around an early strike. With this call, Italy will reach the figure of almost 200 general strikes, sectoral or not, since 2008, 55 of them in the last three years alone: almost one per month over eighteen years, which is a rhythm of the liturgical calendar. The organic crisis is not limited to the state: it also crosses the forms of organization of the class and empties them of their historical function.

The Battle of France

And in the background, the French presidential elections of 2027, with the oligarchies of Paris and an exhausted political staff: Macron without a candidate for 2027. The Republicans in terminal crisis. Marine Le Pen’s National Rally, divided between her popular base and her Atlanticist leadership. A left (La France Insoumise, the PCF, the PS, the Greens) divided between the street, the magical social-democratic fantasies and bureaucratic corruption. And the probable entry into the race of the savior of the elites’ farming, Christine Lagarde, who resigned as president of the ECB while this article was being written. In Spain, in 2027, the general elections. Meloni, unable to save what her rhetoric promised to defend, with Vannacci’s National Future, growing to her right, thanks to her opposition to the war against Russia. De Wever on the defensive. Rama cornered. Merz with a fractured coalition and with a populist, nationalist, anti-globalist right that grows at its expense, by the same opposition to the war. And in Belgrade, the “students” with a parliamentary majority – how they will behave in practice remains to be seen, given the extremely heterogeneous nature of the bloc. Legitimacy is increasingly shifting from Parliament to the streets. Between the time of the squares, which is measured in acts and strikes, and the time of the ballot box, which is measured in years, the bourgeoisie is no longer able to reconcile the rhythm of popular mobilizations with the functioning of its institutions, one of the ways in which its crisis is expressed. In it an organic crisis materializes more and more clearly, that is, according to Gramsci, the moment when the ruling classes cease to organize the consent of the subalterns and have to replace it with naked coercion. A crisis that is no longer only economic or only of government, but of the very form of the State. When it is not convinced, it is forbidden. And in the gap that the regime leaves, the populist, nationalist, anti-globalist right tries to install itself, capturing in Germany the protest against the war that the left leaves free, and the extreme right, blaming immigration everywhere for all the problems, without ever explaining why capital has brought millions of workers to Europe or what a reserve army is, and without saying that the problem is not these exploited workers, but senile capitalism that displaces them. It is barbarism, stupid!

This spring in the autumn bore little resemblance to previous phases of European social unrest: it left the framework of citizens’ rights to pose as a class reorganization, uniting, after many decades, the metropolitan struggle with the provinces and with an anti-imperialist consciousness. In favour of the confederation, the simultaneity in a few weeks and the first victories, with confederations that, dragged by their bases, again called for general strikes that a few years earlier seemed impossible. On the other hand, there was a lack of a common, simple and immediate program that would place at its centre, as an absolute existential urgency for the future of the European working class, the immediate exit of Europe from the war. Each movement fought against its government, with its demands, hoping for circumscribed results, with the risk that the struggle would be exhausted in the dream of returning to a previous “better” situation and, in the end, to an “improved capitalism”.

There was also a lack of coordination between the struggles: the dates of the mobilizations and strikes were dispersed, and each dispersed date was a huge missed opportunity to expand the transnational reach of these moments and to organize unique or common days on a European scale. And there remained the problem of the violence of some groups of young people, as in Paris and Milan, born of the anger and social degradation of the ghetto neighbourhoods of the periphery, but also the lack of party structure: there were not, as in the mass parties of the sixties, militants who did bring order to the movement, although some began to organize. It is the phenomenon, with its contradictions, of the maranza, as stigmatized young people from the periphery are called today in Italy, which the left does not have the capacity to confront due to self-censorship. In these contradictions, the right observes, with interest, the discontent of a part of the population, including the periphery, workers and the people. And the repression sought what it always seeks: to tire, to frighten, to divide. The map of differences showed where each limit was. Today, the million-dollar question is that of 1905: how to transform spontaneity into organization without destroying it.

 Unity and difference

Unity did not annul difference, and difference did not prevent unity. Synchronization was spontaneous, without central coordination; the International that coordinated the great cycles of the past no longer exists as an organization. But the material unity of capital that produced the material unity of contestation remains. In this sense, the spring has shown that the International, before being an organization, is a condition: the internationalisation of capital. The demands that the street formulated (expropriate the empty houses and socialize the patrimony of the funds; end rearmament and build a military industry of its own, autonomous, collectivized and detached from the United States; embargo arms to Israel) start from immediate needs and lead, by their own logic, to the question of who is in charge of the economy: what Trotsky called the Transitional Program. And above all, there is a lack of a party. An organization of the workers capable of uniting the struggles, giving them a program and proposing a political solution. Without this, each wave ends in demoralization or co-optation.

It was, in short, the first mass political condensation of the 21st century in Europe in which the five keys turned at the same time in the same lock, with a non-accidental coincidence. It was the necessary form that the organic crisis of the neoliberal and Europeanist bloc took to mature. The class struggle has its own seasons, and for this reason, it flourished in October. In this transit, the conflict between capital and labour left the classical industrial centre to install itself in circulation and reproduction, and not by a tactical choice, but by the very structure of a tertiary and financialised capitalism, which forces us to reformulate the workers’ and productive centrality, without abandoning it, since it will be the only one capable of giving, as the Italian case demonstrates, the leap in quality in the struggle. Dispossession proved to be the main engine of this phase, and housing, its purest form. The rent that devours wages was the central mechanism for the transfer of surplus value to the financial and rentier fraction. On this material basis grew the subjective basis of radicalism: for the first time since 1968, a European generation did not expect anything from the ascension promised by the diploma, did not defend a lost order or ask for a return to a normality that it knew had brought it to the current situation. And in front of it, an absence of political leadership and a legitimacy conquered by the street, with the general strike, the encampment, the horizontal revolt and the occupation of ministries as responses to a parliamentary regime that no longer processed the demands from below.

In Italy, the most advanced symptom of the crisis of the historical forms of workers’ organization was also seen, the fracture between the rank and file and the confederation, and the reconfiguration of the trade union field, not its simple radicalization, remained as a strategic task. Because the unity of the movement was European and its political organization is not yet. This was the beginning of a movement, not its end. What the coming months decide, from the strikes in November to the ballot boxes of 2027, through the revolts and the maturation of the movements, will determine whether the cycle is encapsulated in bourgeois management or advances towards a pre-revolutionary crisis. The European bourgeoisie has not yet won this battle. Neither has the working class. The correlation of forces will remain open, and its resolution will depend on the ability of the mobilized generation to pose and resolve the question of organization. If the November days, if the ports, the secondary schools, the teachers and the unions meet, the winter could be very different from what the governments expect. Dialectics, the old mole of the revolution reminded us, does not stop, even when it digs under the earth. For years, we were told that the working class no longer existed, that there were only individuals, consumers, isolated citizens and communities. This autumn it appeared again as a class, in the streets, in schools, in ports, on the sea. What has not yet returned is its party, the explicitness of its consciousness and its dream. Its project. That will be the task.

 * Gregório Carboni Maestri, 49, Italian, Belgian and Brazilian, is an architect and university professor. He lives and works in Belgium and Italy. He has worked in Portugal and maintains close relations with Germany. Gr********************@***il.com

Brazil: Lula’s re-election

A historic victory for the working class against imperialism and fascism.

In October 2026, Brazil became the centre of a global dispute, partially and momentarily won by the working class. The wave of street protests against the cost of living, war, the right wing, and imperialism that swept through Europe translated in Brazil into spontaneous and massive support for Lula’s victory.

The re-election was welcomed by the leaders of Mexico, Spain, Russia, China, Iran, and Cuba, and celebrated in various parts of the world, including occupied Palestine. It was a relief not only for Brazilians, but for all those who had seen Trump win the elections of the last two years and impose his right-wing candidates in Latin America. Trump’s reactionary wave achieved seven victories in just 14 months: electing Daniel Noboa in Ecuador; Nasry Asfura in Honduras; José Antonio Kast in Chile; Rodrigo Paz in Bolivia; Laura Fernández in Costa Rica; Keiko Fujimori in Peru; and Abelardo de la Espriella in Colombia. In Argentina, the White House also intervened to reverse the midterm legislative elections, contradicting polls that predicted a resounding defeat for Milei. In October 2025, on the eve of the election, Trump conditioned rescue packages and financial support of around US$40 billion (a US$20 billion currency swap plus an additional credit line of the same value) to the Argentine economy on the continuation of the ultraliberal reforms of the Javier Milei administration. With this not-so-invisible hand of Trump, Milei’s party, La Libertad Avanza, won in both the House and the Senate.

The military defeat against Iran and the collateral effect of the tariffs imposed by Trump on imported goods caused inflation to skyrocket in the US. The electoral defeat of Lula in Brazil is proving to be a watershed moment in halting the offensive of political manipulation by Latin American governments, initiated with the electoral fraud in Honduras and continued with the manipulation of Maduro in Venezuela. The conversion of Latin America into a colonial backyard can be stopped and defeated, not through class conciliation, not through a broad alliance with the right against the far right, not through capitulation to Trump’s ultimatums, but through the mass mobilization of the working class to defeat fascism and imperialism. Even the most conservative American voter dislikes voting for presidents who lead the country to defeat in the military and political adventures of the White House, even more so in unpopular wars like the one against Iran. Marco Rubio, the US Secretary of State, was pressured to swear that the White House did not aid in the illegal escape of Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, a fugitive from Brazilian justice, to the US. Netanyahu, supported by Trump and his family, has just been defeated by the opposition in the Israeli parliamentary elections. All of this adds to the immense internal popular discontent in the US, which tends to defeat Trump’s candidates for governor, senate, and Congress. In this context, Lula’s re-election gains immense international importance, and the “L” becomes a symbol of this rising resistance.

Symbol of Lula’s campaign

In the US, Mexico, Spain, France, Argentina, and Portugal—countries where the left is contesting elections in the coming period against the Trumpist far-right—the improbable and then inevitable victory of Lula represents “a breath of hope,” in the words of Claudia Sheinbaum, the Mexican president (shown below).

When commenting on Brazil’s international dimension, the former Portuguese prime minister paraphrased verses by Vinícius de Moraes to summarize the geopolitical significance of the national political process: ‘Brazilians, forgive me, but the world won the election.’ According to Sócrates, the strengthening of democracy in Brazil represented a decisive brake on the global wave of the far-right and the progression of international authoritarianism. He also pointed out that the multilateral balance of the planet and the leading role of the so-called Global South depend directly on Brazil’s active and sovereign presence in major forums, such as the BRICS bloc. (https://www.brasil247.com/entrevistas/o-presidente-lula-mostrou-ao-mundo-que-a-esquerda-sabe-governar-diz-jose-socrates/)

Lula’s improbable victory had several unprecedented, or at least very rare, achievements. Lula is one of the few presidents elected by popular vote for four terms, like F.D. Roosevelt in the USA. He is the first and only one of working-class and metallurgical origin to achieve this feat. He is the first presidential candidate in Brazil to be defeated in the first round and win in the second round, with the highest vote count in the country’s history, 64 million votes. The candidate of the Trumpist right, Senator Flávio Bolsonaro of the Liberal Party (PL), was victorious in the first round with 56.1 million votes and obtained 3.7 million more, 59.8 million votes in the second round. Even so, he was surpassed by Lula, propelled by the masses who secured him a fourth popular term.

All sectors of the oppressed and exploited population were terrified by the results of the first round, in which the candidates of the fascist right emerged victorious, both for president and for the National Congress, as well as the vast majority of governors. Immediately after Sunday, October 4th, the fascists began announcing the distribution of government positions and the unions began publicizing measures against the Brazilian working population, even before the election was over.

In a climate of “it’s already won,” fuelled by mainstream media, Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta, and the stock market boom, Flávio Bolsonaro’s economic team (composed of names like Daniella Marques, Luiz Felipe Trevisan, and Adolfo Sachsida) felt quite comfortable confessing their intentions in interviews, defending a robust fiscal adjustment plan—nicknamed the “sweep”—of up to R$ 250 billion in public investments. The team debated the elimination of the minimum percentages of revenue that the Union is legally obligated to allocate to health and education, opening the way for deep cuts in these sectors. The plan would mirror the “shock” model implemented by Javier Milei in Argentina, focused on the destruction of public services, a severe reduction in the size of the State, and Administrative Reform. The separation of the readjustment of retirement pensions, INSS benefits, and social assistance benefits (such as the BPC) from the value of the minimum wage was also discussed. Critics warned that this would freeze the purchasing power of more than 40 million beneficiaries who depend on the minimum pension. The plan’s progress indicated an aggressive resumption of the National Privatization Program, generating fears of the handover of strategic public assets and the loosening of environmental licenses to accelerate mining and oil exploration projects. Cuts of this magnitude would generate a sharp economic slowdown and unemployment in the short term. As household consumption accounts for about 70% of Brazil’s GDP, the decoupling of pensions and the slowdown in social investments would directly threaten domestic economic activity.

Still reeling from the defeat and fearing the return of Bolsonarism to government and power, a process of expanding popular demonstrations and mobilization unfolded, regardless of the Lula campaign leadership and the PT party. This began immediately with spontaneous student actions by young people and social movements that were not restricted to the traditional party structures of the PT, the most important party in the country’s history over the last 50 years, but constrained by a bourgeois leadership. A striking example was the “Youth in the Streets for Democracy” demonstration, which went from Candelária to Cinelândia in Rio de Janeiro, in addition to student actions at UFF in Niterói. International PT groups also organized demonstrations in cities abroad such as New York, Lisbon, Paris, and London under the slogan “Lula president, Lula world leader!”. Throughout the week, the movement grew in several cities across the country until it culminated in the massive mobilization on Paulista Avenue with Lula’s presence on October 11th, which brought together hundreds of thousands of demonstrators, politicians, artists, and influencers. Despite the inept leadership of the Workers’ Party, a digital strategy was devised to organize the popular spontaneity on social media. Digital tools and WhatsApp groups—such as the “Lula’s Army” channel, which gathered 10 million digital activists and was coordinated by Janones—scaled up online engagement, replicating videos, agendas, and “missions” to disseminate content beyond the traditional left-wing bubble.

Faced with electoral fatigue and the fear of losing votes in the final stretch of the second round, Flávio Bolsonaro himself and his aides changed their public tone in the last weeks of October. They began to modulate their discourse, classifying the benefit cuts as “fake news” and announcing a “package of goodies” (such as debt refinancing and tax breaks) to try to contain the damage and calm the electorate. But by then it was too late, the crime had already been revealed in advance and the damage had already been done.

The massive popular movement, unprecedented in several small inland cities and unseen for decades in capitals and larger cities, meant that the presence on the streets and on social media directly reflected in the reduction of abstention, which fell from 33,469,244 in the first round to 30,509,005 voters in the second round, a difference of more than 2.9 million people. From 21.08% to 19.22%, the lowest abstention rate in 20 years. In addition to the drop in absences, the second round also registered a decrease in the number of blank and null votes. In total, 1,430,496 voters cast blank votes, equivalent to 1.12%. In the first round there were 2,300,798 blank votes (1.84%). Null votes in the second round totalled 2,723,305, equivalent to 2.12% of the total. In the first round, there were 3,674,249 invalid votes, or 2.93% of the total. As a result, Lula, who trailed Senator Flávio Bolsonaro in the first round with 53 million votes, gained more than 10 million votes between the first and second rounds, reaching 64 million votes.

This movement influenced and was influenced by the victory for workers and the left in a decades-long struggle against employers and the right: the reduction of the weekly work schedule from 6×1 to 5×2 and from 44 to 40 hours. Shortly after the first round of voting, Congress approved a new Proposed Amendment to the Constitution (PEC) establishing the biggest change to the work schedule since 1988: the progressive reduction of the maximum weekly hours from 44 to 42 (expected to take effect approximately 60 days after promulgation, at the end of 2026) and to 40 hours per week in December 2027, sealing the end of the traditional 6×1 work schedule.

 The results of the first round mobilized the population against the return of Bolsonaro.

The PL won six gubernatorial races in the first round, but did not win any in the second round. Even so, it emerged from the polls as the party with the largest number of governors, in addition to the largest blocs in the Chamber of Deputies (121) and the Federal Senate (19 elected this year). 23 governors are from the right or from parties of the Bolsonaro movement such as PP, PSD, Republicanos, MDB, Podemos, PSDB.

The PT only elected four governors (Bahia, Ceará, Piauí, and Rio Grande do Norte). In these states, just like Lula, the PT governors practice neoliberal policies and are sometimes more repressive than the right wing itself, as in the case of Bahia, where the military police kill more poor people than the police of right-wing governments (Reports on this from Piauí and Pública ).

 The gravity of the threat that popular mobilization defeated.

 If Flávio Bolsonaro (Liberal Party) were to win the elections, he would release a legion of coup plotters, annul Criminal Action 2668, for which [Jair] Bolsonaro was sentenced to 27 years and three months in prison, and Braga Netto to 26 years. He would release the coup-plotting generals who orchestrated Operation “Green and Yellow Dagger,” which planned to assassinate Lula, the vice-president, Geraldo Alckmin, and the Supreme Court Justice, Alexandre de Moraes. He would also pardon the mob that was arrested after the assault on the three branches of the Brazilian republic on January 8, 2023. He would also release banker Daniel Vorcaro, owner of Banco Master, the linchpin of the largest and most extensive corruption scheme ever revealed (traditional and larger banks certainly have larger and more shielded schemes), as well as his partners in various spheres of power and business, who would be released or have their cases dropped.

Legal experts and liberal analysts pointed out that Senator Bolsonaro’s proposals and statements represented institutional risks and an authoritarian drift aimed at undermining democracy and weakening the 1988 Constitution. The candidate explicitly stated that he intended to use the conservative majority elected in the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate to alter the Brazilian Constitution. Critics and opponents pointed out that the intention to rewrite or profoundly modify the constitutional text would jeopardize fundamental rights guaranteed within it. The unprecedented advance in the first round of the election of federal deputies and senators by the PL party further tilts the already reactionary and oligarchic Centrão bloc to the right. Now, these fascist-like parliamentarians will have even greater weight to extinguish various social and labour achievements, as well as to approve several laws attacking the working class. The new reactionary majority will also be able to more easily obtain the two-thirds majority of the 513 deputies, that is, the 342 votes needed to approve the impeachment of the president, as well as the simple majority of 41 of the 80 senators for the same process of removing the president from office, when it goes to the upper house of the legislature.

Had he been elected, in addition to being able to appoint up to four new judges to the Supreme Federal Court (STF), Flávio’s program included a strong “judicial reform” focused on limiting the power of the Supreme Federal Court. Among the proposed measures were the end of the STF’s original criminal jurisdiction to judge parliamentarians, the strict limitation of monocratic decisions, and changes to the rules for appointing new justices.

All this political power became ammunition for the fear of a return to Bolsonaro. Lula’s campaign began to denounce to those still undecided, those who had abstained or cast blank votes, the danger that the concentration of so much power in the hands of any government represented. It is estimated that up to 5% of Flávio’s electorate voted for Lula in the second round.

In a 2025 interview, Senator Flávio Bolsonaro mentioned the possibility of direct interference between the branches of government and the “use of force.” Flávio also announced plans for alignment with the international far-right, highlighting the promise to involve members of Donald Trump’s government directly in Brazil’s presidential transition, which was classified as a serious institutional threat and a threat to Brazilian sovereignty, practically reverting the country to colonial status, where the president would be a mere administrator handing over national wealth to the US. One of the main resources coveted today by imperialism and Big Tech companies are Brazil’s rare earth and niobium minerals.

Rare earth elements are 17 chemical elements essential for the production of super-magnets that are the basis of new technologies (cell phones, electric cars, drones). As far as research has shown, Brazil possesses 21%, the second largest reserve of rare earth elements in the world (the largest reserves are in China), and could have much more than that based on new research. Vietnam is in third place, with 17%. The USA possesses only 1%, as does Greenland.

Niobium is a critical and strategic mineral, essential for manufacturing stronger and lighter superalloy steels, turbines, rockets, and superconductors (used in magnetic resonance imaging machines). Brazil stands out because it holds approximately 98% of the planet’s economically viable reserves and dominates world production (operated mainly by CBMM in Araxá, Minas Gerais).

Government plans and guidelines associated with his platform included restrictions on academic freedom in universities. During the campaign, the opposition also denounced legal attacks against popular communicators and cultural pages on social media.

His government plan included an authoritarian shift in public security based on the model of Nayib Bukele (El Salvador), proposing the creation of mega-prisons with maximum security, chemical castration of rapists (his own vice-presidential candidate, Alfredo Gaspar, from the PL party, is the target of a request from the Federal Police to the Supreme Federal Court (STF) to investigate an accusation of rape of a vulnerable person), among other measures seen by human rights defenders as loopholes for the summary execution of prisoners.

In turn, the candidate was clearly identified with banditry in all its variations: fraud, receiving money from the arch-corrupt banker Vorcaro, kickbacks from parliamentary offices, money laundering, international prostitution and human trafficking networks, and liberalisation for the actions of paramilitary armies that are the militias. A bill (such as PL 3.723/2019) defended by the Senator, which alters the Disarmament Statute and proposes removing the mandatory identification numbering on ammunition casings purchased by security forces, greatly hindered the investigation of crimes and the illegal arms trade, making it difficult to trace the diversion of weapons from state arsenals to criminal factions and militias, in addition to hindering the investigation of crimes (as exemplified in historical cases such as that of Marielle Franco), scandalized the electorate. During debates in the election campaign, Flávio Bolsonaro downplayed the proposal and called the discussion about removing the numbering from the bullets a “minor detail”.

If Bolsonarism were to return to government, it would try to avoid all the “mistakes” that led to its loss by popular vote, that is, it would establish a dictatorship to perpetuate itself in power, it would institute torture, if necessary “killing 30,000,” as Bolsonaro has already declared (Senate) https://www2.senado.leg.br/bdsf/bitstream/handle/id/573673/noticia.html?sequence=1&isAllowed=ye, and it would establish “prisoner of war camps – CPGs,” as discovered in conversations between members of special army groups, the black kids. (https://oglobo.globo.com/politica/noticia/2024/11/27/militar-questionou-sobre-campo-de-prisioneiros-de-guerra-em-grupo-que-tratou-sobre-golpe-auschwitz-leia-mensagem.ghtml).

 The difficulties in consolidating the fascist project in the age of financialization.

Trump and Bolsonaro are politicians who do not hide their desires to transform their governments into dictatorships, although they deny being characterised as fascists because it doesn’t fit with the reputation of fascism that imperialism itself built to legitimise itself and establish its doctrine of “defender of the free world” after World War II. Government and State are two different things. They instituted several measures in this direction, such as the immigrant hunting group, ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement Service), a federal law enforcement agency linked to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. But the aspirations of a government are not always executed or developed in the state it governs. Neither Trump nor Bolsonaro managed to transform the states they governed into fascist states. Less because the structural conditions of the era of financialization of the imperialist economy do not allow it, than because of the desire of the mafia gangs that administered and administer the White House and the Planalto Palace. We developed this explanation in “Neoliberalism, neofascism and financialization – Could the neoliberal state evolve into a neofascist state?”

The communist revolutionary Leon Trotsky, who analysed the rise of Nazi-fascism in his time, explains both the essence of fascism and how a state becomes fascist:

“From fascism the bourgeoisie demands a thorough job; once it has resorted to methods of civil war, it insists on having peace for a period of years. And the fascist agency, by utilizing the petty bourgeoisie as a battering ram, by overwhelming all obstacles in its path, does a thorough job. After fascism is victorious, finance capital directly and immediately gathers into its hands, as in a vise of steel, all the organs and institutions of sovereignty, the executive administrative, and educational powers of the state: the entire state apparatus together with the army, the municipalities, the universities, the schools, the press, the trade unions, and the co-operatives. When a state turns fascist, it does not mean only that the forms and methods of government are changed in accordance the patterns set by Mussolini – the changes in this sphere ultimately play a minor role – but it means first of all for the most part that the workers’ organizations are annihilated; that the proletariat is reduced to an amorphous state; and that a system of administration is created which penetrates deeply into the masses and which serves to frustrate the independent crystallization of the proletariat. Therein precisely is the gist of fascism …” (https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/works/1944/1944-fas.htm#p2).

Thus, it becomes clear that neither Trump nor Bolsonaro, and even less so the other contemporary versions of the international fascist movement, achieved what Mussolini, Hitler, Franco, Salazar, or Tojo achieved in their time.

The Bolsonaro family was defeated in the presidential elections, but Bolsonarism, as a far-right fascist movement, did not suffer a decisive political defeat. It will continue to influence national politics in favour of the most radical interests of big imperialist capital and its local partners. Immediately after the second round, it unleashed a reprisal against workers who voted for Lula, indigenous people, women, and LGBTQ+ individuals, with dismissals, evictions, threats, physical assaults, terrorist attacks, and dozens of murders in a McCarthyist and criminal ideological persecution. Fascism must be crushed by the upcoming anti-fascist and anti-imperialist struggles.

We believe that the historic mass uprising of workers in the form of Lula’s electoral campaign, which occurred in this second round, will not allow the setbacks sought by those defeated in the presidential elections, but victorious in the parliamentary elections. This movement of the working class may still achieve new gains, such as zero fares on public transport (not just on weekends), an achievement that should have been defended by the PT governments in 2013 and that could have thwarted the growth of the right wing from then on and the entire subsequent coup process, supported by popular frustration with the PT. From 2013 to 2026, more than 150 cities in the country have already established zero fares on public transport.

The working class has been learning to take advantage of the class struggle, even when fighting on enemy territory. It has been achieving victories in extremely difficult situations and unexpected triumphs, both in bourgeois elections and on social media manipulated by Big Tech, where, despite all the political limitations of this enlistment, it participated in a disciplined and centralized manner in the “Lula’s Army” to mitigate the disproportionate nature of the struggle in this arena, contain fake news, and spread information relevant to Lula’s campaign and to Federal Deputy André Janones of the Rede Sustentabilidade party. The workers achieved a major electoral victory, a turnaround victory coupled with a historic labour victory, with a reduction of 4 hours of work per week, something not seen since the 1988 Constitution, when the workweek was reduced from 48 to 44 hours. Despite the obstacles, the precariousness of labour relations, and the class conciliation policy that, to some extent, fosters frustration and recruitment into anti-PT sentiment among workers, the working class has achieved economic gains in recent years, such as reduced unemployment and complete exemption from income tax for those earning up to 5,000 reais, a bracket that covers 90% of the salaried population. Furthermore, despite a parliamentary majority in both houses of Congress, the demoralization caused by the imprisonment of the father, Jair Messias, and the flight of the Bolsonaro sons (Eduardo and Flávio) to the USA, as well as the contradictions and disputes over Bolsonaro’s political capital, should weaken the right wing for a brief and imminent period.

The sheer size of the popular mobilization in Brazil disrupted and thwarted the ongoing coup, orchestrated between the White House, Meta, the Superior Electoral Court, the anti-PT right wing, the mainstream media, and research institutes that were prepared to do in Brazil what they did in seven other countries on the continent. The spontaneous struggle went far beyond the leadership of the traditional Brazilian left, incorporating thousands of people into political activism in this second round. However, spontaneity, dispersion, or merely virtual activity will not be enough to ensure the defeat of coup and impeachment attempts that representatives of Trump or another imperialist ruler may try to impose in the future. It is necessary to organize popular discontent and contest the direction of the PT itself, using this victory as leverage for the continental defeat of imperialism, for the unity of the peoples to crush its fascist creation, and to continue the struggle for socialist revolution in Brazil and the world.

We are moving forward, we have won, and we will win again!

Communist Manifesto – parts 3 and 4

Communist Manifesto – part 3: Socialist and Communist Literature, and part 4: Position of the Communists in Relation to the Various Existing Opposition Parties

The following is the notes/text of a presentation delivered by a Consistent Democrats speaker on 25th October. The recording of the presentation and discussion is here

These two sections conclude the Manifesto. And it has to be said that the overwhelming bulk of the real political substance is in the first two parts. So, we have already looked at the most important parts of the Manifesto.

Part 3, on “Socialist and Communist Literature” is very historically specific. It consists of a series of different types of literature of a variety of different socialist trends at this very early stage of the growth and evolution of the workers movement.

Since these are all trends that the early communist movement had to deal with at the time, these are significant, but it has to be said that they bear only a very limited and superficial resemblance to those which exist today.

And they often involve the reaction of other classes to the developing struggle between the working class and early capitalism.

So, Marx and Engels talk about ‘feudal socialism’, which they characterised thus:

“In order to arouse sympathy, the aristocracy was obliged to lose sight, apparently, of its own interests, and to formulate their indictment against the bourgeoisie in the interest of the exploited working class alone. Thus, the aristocracy took their revenge by singing lampoons on their new masters and whispering in his ears sinister prophesies of coming catastrophe.

“In this way arose feudal Socialism: half lamentation, half lampoon; half an echo of the past, half menace of the future; at times, by its bitter, witty and incisive criticism, striking the bourgeoisie to the very heart’s core; but always ludicrous in its effect, through total incapacity to comprehend the march of modern history.

“The aristocracy, in order to rally the people to them, waved the proletarian alms-bag in front for a banner. But the people, so often as it joined them, saw on their hindquarters the old feudal coats of arms, and deserted with loud and irreverent laughter.”

Well might the masses laugh, because … “What they upbraid the bourgeoisie with is not so much that it creates a proletariat as that it creates a revolutionary proletariat.”

And not surprisingly “they join in all coercive measures against the working class; and in ordinary life, despite their high-falutin phrases”

Then briefly they mention Clerical Socialism, only to dismiss it thus:

“Nothing is easier than to give Christian asceticism a Socialist tinge. Has not Christianity declaimed against private property, against marriage, against the State? Has it not preached in the place of these, charity and poverty, celibacy and mortification of the flesh, monastic life and Mother Church? Christian Socialism is but the holy water with which the priest consecrates the heart-burnings of the aristocrat.”

At this very early stage, this sounds a bit strange, as many are familiar with the role of non-conformist religion in the later workers movement, e.g., Methodism in British Labour, etc.

But this is at a very early stage, 1847, and had hardly been seen as yet.

Then there are various kinds of petty bourgeois socialism.

The petit bourgeoisie, in various forms, fluctuates between the workers and the capitalists.  But

“The individual members of this class, however, are being constantly hurled down into the proletariat by the action of competition, and, as modern industry develops, they even see the moment approaching when they will completely disappear as an independent section of modern society”

And in countries with a large peasantry, like France, such ideas become very widespread:

“…it was natural that writers who sided with the proletariat against the bourgeoisie should use, in their criticism of the bourgeois regime, the standard of the peasant and petty bourgeois, and from the standpoint of these intermediate classes, should take up the cudgels for the working class. Thus arose petty-bourgeois Socialism. Sismondi was the head of this school, not only in France but also in England.”

And Marx and Engels point out its self-defeating nature: “This school of Socialism dissected with great acuteness the contradictions in the conditions of modern production”

And yet:

“In its positive aims, however, this form of Socialism aspires either to restoring the old means of production and of exchange, and with them the old property relations, and the old society, or to cramping the modern means of production and of exchange within the framework of the old property relations that have been, and were bound to be, exploded by those means. In either case, it is both reactionary and Utopian.”

There is some resemblance to this with petty bourgeois radicalism today, though looking not to a previous mode of production, but to a kinder and more natural form of capitalism.

Though again, the parallels are superficial, as this form of petty bourgeois politics did not endure:

“Ultimately, when stubborn historical facts had dispersed all intoxicating effects of self-deception, this form of Socialism ended in a miserable fit of the blues.”

Then there was German, or True socialism

This is the hardest to understand, as it seems like an eccentric and sect-like attempt to impose on German society of the mid-19th Century, the kind of political life that existed in France given that feudalism had already been overthrown. But Germany did not have that economic development, and it appeared like some kind of fantasy:

“German philosophers, would-be philosophers, and beaux esprits (men of letters), eagerly seized on this literature, only forgetting, that when these writings immigrated from France into Germany, French social conditions had not immigrated along with them. In contact with German social conditions, this French literature lost all its immediate practical significance and assumed a purely literary aspect. Thus, to the German philosophers of the Eighteenth Century, the demands of the first French Revolution were nothing more than the demands of ‘Practical Reason’ in general, and the utterance of the will of the revolutionary French bourgeoisie signified, in their eyes, the laws of pure Will, of Will as it was bound to be, of true human Will generally.”

I must admit, that this does seem a bit like reading Hegel, whose elaborate dialectical logic is all worked out without regard for material reality. Marx was compelled to turn his whole logic on its head. Hegel was a supporter of autocracy, though also admired Napoleon.

“To the absolute governments, with their following of parsons, professors, country squires, and officials, it served as a welcome scarecrow against the threatening bourgeoisie.”

“While this ‘True’ Socialism thus served the government as a weapon for fighting the German bourgeoisie, it, at the same time, directly represented a reactionary interest, the interest of German Philistines. In Germany, the petty-bourgeois class, a relic of the sixteenth century, and since then constantly cropping up again under the various forms, is the real social basis of the existing state of things.

To preserve this class is to preserve the existing state of things in Germany. The industrial and political supremacy of the bourgeoisie threatens it with certain destruction — on the one hand, from the concentration of capital; on the other, from the rise of a revolutionary proletariat. ‘True’ Socialism appeared to kill these two birds with one stone. It spread like an epidemic.”

It appeared as a petty bourgeois socialism in a society where the aristocracy was still in power, and it tailed after the reaction, as opposed to in France where the aristocracy had been overthrown. It was a reactionary relic.

“It proclaimed the German nation to be the model nation, and the German petty Philistine to be the typical man. To every villainous meanness of this model man, it gave a hidden, higher, Socialistic interpretation, the exact contrary of its real character. It went to the extreme length of directly opposing the “brutally destructive” tendency of Communism, and of proclaiming its supreme and impartial contempt of all class struggles. With very few exceptions, all the so-called Socialist and Communist publications that now (1847) circulate in Germany belong to the domain of this foul and enervating literature.”

Then you have what Marx and Engels called ConservativeorBourgeois socialism.

“A part of the bourgeoisie is desirous of redressing social grievances in order to secure the continued existence of bourgeois society.

“To this section belong economists, philanthropists, humanitarians, improvers of the condition of the working class, organisers of charity, members of societies for the prevention of cruelty to animals, temperance fanatics, hole-and-corner reformers of every imaginable kind. This form of socialism has, moreover, been worked out into complete systems.”

They mentioned Proudhon and his Philosophy of Poverty.

I suppose you could view this as the ancestor of bourgeois reformism generally. Though they treat it as fatuous:

“It is summed up in the phrase: the bourgeois is a bourgeois — for the benefit of the working class”

Then we have Critical Utopian Socialism and Communism. M&E take this more seriously, as a forerunner of a more powerful workers’ movement.

“The first direct attempts of the proletariat to attain its own ends, made in times of universal excitement, when feudal society was being overthrown, necessarily failed, owing to the then undeveloped state of the proletariat, as well as to the absence of the economic conditions for its emancipation, conditions that had yet to be produced, and could be produced by the impending bourgeois epoch alone. The revolutionary literature that accompanied these first movements of the proletariat had necessarily a reactionary character. It inculcated universal asceticism and social levelling in its crudest form.”

The Socialist and Communist systems, properly so called, those of Saint-Simon, Fourier, Owen, and others, spring into existence in the early undeveloped period, described above, of the struggle between proletariat and bourgeoisie.

They noted what was common to all these systems – the attempt to invent a system that can ‘solve’ the class struggle:

“Historical action is to yield to their personal inventive action; historically created conditions of emancipation to fantastic ones; and the gradual, spontaneous class organisation of the proletariat to an organisation of society especially contrived by these inventors. Future history resolves itself, in their eyes, into the propaganda and the practical carrying out of their social plans.

In the formation of their plans, they are conscious of caring chiefly for the interests of the working class, as being the most suffering class. Only from the point of view of being the most suffering class does the proletariat exist for them.”

But this really flows from “The undeveloped state of the class struggle”, and results in a situation where:  “Socialists of this kind … consider themselves far superior to all class antagonisms”

However, at that point, it could not really be otherwise, because these concepts came into being when:

“… the proletariat is still in a very undeveloped state and has but a fantastic conception of its own position, correspond with the first instinctive yearnings of that class for a general reconstruction of society.

M&E are not dismissive of the utopians though, because:

“…these Socialist and Communist publications contain also a critical element. They attack every principle of existing society. Hence, they are full of the most valuable materials for the enlightenment of the working class. The practical measures proposed in them — such as the abolition of the distinction between town and country, of the family, of the carrying on of industries for the account of private individuals, and of the wage system, the proclamation of social harmony, the conversion of the function of the state into a mere superintendence of production — all these proposals point solely to the disappearance of class antagonisms which were, at that time, only just cropping up, and which, in these publications, are recognised in their earliest indistinct and undefined forms only”

And they note the paradox:

“The significance of Critical-Utopian Socialism and Communism bears an inverse relation to historical development. In proportion as the modern class struggle develops and takes definite shape, this fantastic standing apart from the contest, these fantastic attacks on it, lose all practical value and all theoretical justification. Therefore, although the originators of these systems were, in many respects, revolutionary, their disciples have, in every case, formed mere reactionary sects. They hold fast by the original views of their masters, in opposition to the progressive historical development of the proletariat.”

Therefore, they underline their nature as a sectarian expression of a movement that has not yet found its feet. And indeed, the utopians fear it doing so:

 They, therefore, violently oppose all political action on the part of the working class; such action, according to them, can only result from blind unbelief in the new Gospel.

The Owenites in England, and the Fourierists in France, respectively, oppose the Chartists and the Réformistes.”

From there, we go onto the final section of the Manifesto: Position of the Communists in Relation to the Various Existing Opposition Parties, which is very short.

It really reiterates what Marx and Engels said earlier, that the communists fight for immediate demands of the class, but always keep in mind its historic interests:

“The Communists fight for the attainment of the immediate aims, for the enforcement of the momentary interests of the working class; but in the movement of the present, they also represent and take care of the future of that movement. In France, the Communists ally with the Social-Democrats against the conservative and radical bourgeoisie, reserving, however, the right to take up a critical position in regard to phases and illusions traditionally handed down from the great Revolution.”

And it goes through how they work with other parties in  Switzerland and Poland, as examples.

But Germany was central; the approach of the revolution of 1848 was apparent in 1847

“In Germany, they fight with the bourgeoisie whenever it acts in a revolutionary way, against the absolute monarchy, the feudal squirearchy, and the petty bourgeoisie.

But they never cease, for a single instant, to instil into the working class the clearest possible recognition of the hostile antagonism between bourgeoisie and proletariat… in order that, after the fall of the reactionary classes in Germany, the fight against the bourgeoisie itself may immediately begin.

The Communists turn their attention chiefly to Germany, because that country is on the eve of a bourgeois revolution that is bound to be carried out under more advanced conditions of European civilisation … than that of England was in the seventeenth, and France in the eighteenth century, and because the bourgeois revolution in Germany will be but the prelude to an immediately following proletarian revolution.”

And thus, the Manifesto concludes:

“In short, the Communists everywhere support every revolutionary movement against the existing social and political order of things.

In all these movements, they bring to the front, as the leading question in each, the property question, no matter what its degree of development at the time.

Finally, they labour everywhere for the union and agreement of the democratic parties of all countries.

The Communists disdain to conceal their views and aims. They openly declare that their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions. Let the ruling classes tremble at a Communistic revolution. The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win.

Working Men of All Countries, Unite!

“Pabloism” and Third-Campism – Yesterday and Today

This Red Partisan supplement was distributed at a Spartacist League public forum in London on 17th October, where they discussed the new issue of Spartacist, concerning their own recent 9th International Conference.

The new issue of the English Language international organ of the International Communist League (Fourth Internationalist), Spartacist issue 71, September 2026, has an innovative article by Vincent David titled “Fourth International After World War 2 – How Trotskyism Fractured”. The thesis he puts forward is an important corrective to the conceits of many ‘Trotskyists’ today; he points out that a fundamental disorientation overcame pretty much the entire Fourth International by the end of WWII. So fundamental was this that it is questionable whether the movement could be regarded as a revolutionary force.

His thesis is that the FI completely failed to understand that the post-war situation was fundamentally different to the sketchy predictions of Trotsky and the FI leadership before the war. Instead of a social crisis and economic collapse of European and US capitalism, the conquest of imperialist hegemony by the United States enabled it to both save European capitalism economically, and reduce the European imperialist powers to its vassals. Instead of the disintegration and collapse of the Stalinist bureaucracy in the USSR, the titanic struggle against the 1941 Nazi invasion drove the Nazis back to Berlin and their doom. This ended with the  bureaucratic overthrow of capitalism from the Baltic to the Adriatic, giving the impetus and broader context for the overthrow of capitalism in China, Korea, Vietnam, later Cuba and a huge political accelerant for the destruction of the European colonial empires by mass-based nationalist movements after WWII.

He points to the failure of any section of the FI to fully grasp what happened, and put forward a concrete revolutionary perspective at the time. He  characterised thus the reactions of the main leaders of the FI, who were to become leaders of different factions, and then separate, counterposed organisations:

“The leaders of the movement—from Michel Pablo and Ernest Mandel, who emerged from the underground in Europe, to James P. Cannon in the U.S.—proved incapable of squaring this new reality with the literal text of the 1938 Transitional Program. Rather than responding to new problems with new answers, they clung to outdated predictions and retreated into a defensive, rigid orthodoxy. Year after year, official documents and resolutions stubbornly predicted an imminent economic meltdown, the rise of bonapartism in Europe and the coming World War III, completely blind to the capitalist stabilization occurring in Europe.”

[…]

“Stuck in sterile orthodoxy, the Fourth International was incapable of understanding how the Cold War was forcing Stalinist and nationalist leaders into confrontation with the American empire and its imperial partners. Because they could not grasp these living dynamics, they dismissed mass support for these leaderships as mere subjective and temporary confusion. Unable to engage the real contradictions within these movements, the International retreated into an abstract, Europe-centric framework—paying lip service to the colonial revolution while remaining politically blind to its true significance and specific tasks.”

Such documents as the US SWP’s Theses on the American Revolution predicted imminent economic collapse and the eruption of major struggles, and were completely at odds with the way post-war development was actually progressing.

He then quotes Trotsky from Lessons of October that ““The party which does not keep step with the historical tasks of its own class becomes, or runs the risk of becoming, the indirect tool of other classes” and goes on to demonstrate that the FI leaders embraced a Stalinophobic position, calling for the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Eastern Europe in 1946. In 1948 the Second World Congress of the FI’s main document was titled “Against Wall St and the Kremlin” – a third-campist thrust. The FI rejected the idea that Stalinists could lead any overturn of capitalism, which disarmed them before first the Yugoslav revolution, then the Chinese revolution. This generated a confused mixture of illusions in Tito particular, and a belief that his regime was no longer Stalinist. The US SWP failed to defend North Korea for several months at the start of the Korean war. Comrade David sums up the events that the FI was failing to analyse correctly by saying:

“…the International spent the years leading up to 1948 claiming it was impossible for movements under Stalinist leadership to carry out any social overturn. In China, as Communist forces led by Mao were inflicting one defeat after another on the nationalist Guomindang, the Fourth International insisted that the CP was capable only of betrayal. Worse even, Chinese Trotskyists advocated a ceasefire in the civil war and actually opposed the victory of the Communist forces! In East Europe, as the ruling classes were systematically liquidated by the Red Army, the Fourth International doubled down on denying reality, insisting at the 1948 Congress that these states remained fully capitalist. The fear that accepting reality would lead to conciliating Stalinism was paralyzing the comrades.”

Pabloism emerges

Subsequently, the head of the FI International Secretariat, Michel Pablo, reacted with his (in)famous 1951 document Where Are We Going?, which advocated deep entryism into particularly Stalinist, but also social democratic parties, believing that a ‘new world reality” had rendered Stalinist parties centrist, capable of “roughly outlining a revolutionary orientation” and that the job of Trotskyists was to push these parties to the left.  This split the FI in 1953 with an international faction led by the US SWP denouncing Pablo as ‘liquidationist’.

Comradely David’s talk is ground-breaking when he says:

“I am going to do something quite dangerous and unprecedented here. I am going to defend Pablo on a number of points. It is essential to cut through the rigid dogmas of the traditional anti-Pablo camp, which our own tendency has, in some cases, repeated. Pablo was trying to grapple with real life; his fatal error was drawing non-revolutionary conclusions from it.”

He goes on to partially defend Pablo without endorsing his overall scheme, which he does regard as liquidationist:

“The anti-Pabloites raised a hue and cry, denouncing Pablo for viewing the world through the prism of two camps—the imperialist camp led by the U.S. on the one hand, and the camp of the USSR and the colonial revolution. The anti-Pabloites claimed Pablo was erasing the fundamental class struggle between the bourgeoisie and the working class. This was a rigid, undialectical critique. During the Cold War, the global class struggle was objectively refracted through the concrete antagonism between U.S. imperialism and the Soviet bloc—just as today, it is refracted through the antagonism between the U.S. and China. This does not mean class struggle ceases to exist within these blocs. Social reality is made of multiple layers. But to deny that the world consisted of a struggle between the imperialist and Soviet camps in the name of a ‘pure’ bourgeois-versus-worker line of battle leads immediately to ‘Third Campism,’ which always ends up capitulating to imperialism.”

He also defended aspects of Pablo’s entryism perspective, without endorsing Pablo’s non-revolutionary conclusion about its purpose:

“…it was entirely correct for small propaganda groups to seek entry into mass Stalinist or nationalist organizations, even with a long-term perspective. Whether this is possible or how to do it depends on the concrete. … If the raw material of the vanguard was to be found inside the CPs or colonial liberation movements, while the Fourth International had only small forces, then it was vital to have a perspective to enter. The problem was not the tactic; it was the political justification for it….”

And he points out that the criticism of Pablo’s opponents was generally Stalinophobic:

“Many accused Pablo of revising the nature of Stalinism. He definitely did—but not always in the way the anti-Pabloites claimed. The SWP majority’s main line of attack against Pabloites was the mantra: Stalinism is counterrevolutionary through and through. … Such formulations are not only disorienting. They are false”.

[…]

“The smashing of a capitalist state, the destruction of landlordism, the expulsion of imperialism—even if carried out under bureaucratic control—is the opposite of counterrevolutionary! It is highly progressive. Furthermore, in China, Yugoslavia, Vietnam and elsewhere, social revolutions were the product of powerful revolutionary upsurges of the masses, pushing Stalinist leaders to go way beyond what they wanted. While Pablo did prettify those forces, his opponents simply wrote off the deep, living contradictions within those movements. The labelling of social revolutions as ‘counterrevolutionary’ was just a lazy way to sweep a problem away rather than solving it. It was also the surest way to guarantee the isolation and discrediting of Trotskyists.”

And he explains precisely what is wrong with Pabloism:

“The problem is the following: the seizure of power in one country does not complete the revolution, but only initiates it. As long as imperialism remains, the conquests of a single country continue to be subject to imperialist asphyxiation and the threat of reversal. Therefore, a revolutionary orientation can be nothing but a conscious strategy for world revolution. This is what the early Comintern was built for.

And this is not the path the Chinese, Yugoslav or Korean Communist Parties were following. They did not ‘cease to be Stalinist Parties.’ Pablo reduced Stalinism to the following of orders from Moscow. This is not what Stalinism is fundamentally. Stalinism is the subordination of the world revolution to the building of socialism in one country, which leads to seeking an illusory peaceful coexistence with imperialism. It arises from the interests of a privileged layer, separated from the masses and caught between them and world imperialism.

Tito leaned on U.S. imperialism against the USSR, leading to his total capitulation in the face of the Korean War. The CPC’s foreign policy was geared toward preserving the People’s Republic of China at the expense of the world revolution, as seen with the huge pressure it put on the Vietnamese CP to accept partition in 1954 or its later betrayal of the Indonesian CP.

Of course, Pablo was correct to argue to support these revolutions. He was correct to argue that Trotskyists had to link themselves to the masses under Stalinist leadership, including through entry tactics. What was fatal in his tactics was that they were all motivated not by the need to build a revolutionary current within them, but by the illusion that the ‘objective process’ would push Communist parties to become revolutionary. This notion was then quickly extended to all sorts of forces, from the MNR in Bolivia, to Ben Bella in Algeria and even to the left wing of the Labour Party!”

The conclusion he draws is:

“The task of the era was to defeat the American empire. The only coherent way the Fourth International could challenge Tito, Mao, all the CPs and the nationalist leaders was on the terrain of the world revolution. This isn’t an abstraction. It meant developing a serious strategy that sought to defend the workers states based on the intensification of the class struggle abroad against imperialism. And from this standpoint denounce the CPs’ accommodation to imperialism as well as their narrow and nationalist strategies to defend the revolutions at the expense of workers, national minorities and the international proletariat.”

His criticism of the ‘Anti-Pabloites” is damning:

“While Pablo openly tailed Stalinist and nationalist movements, the International Committee retreated into a thoroughly sectarian, sterile, and reality-denying approach to those same movements. … And one of the most damning indictments of this split was its geography. By 1953, the majority of the Fourth International’s membership was likely located in the colonial and semicolonial world—across Latin America and Asia. However, at its creation, the bulk of the International Committee was based in imperialist countries, with the majority of members from the colonial and semi-colonial world staying with Pablo.

And this is the tragedy of the 1953 fracture. The Trotskyist movement split into two broken halves, neither of which could offer a coherent, revolutionary answer to Stalinist and nationalist forces in the fight to defeat the American empire.”

And in the introduction, he puts forward the following critique of contemporary Trotskyism, which certainly strikes home in its description of what has happened to the Trotskyist movement:

“By 1953, the Fourth International had fractured in a fatal split. And those splinters would themselves split again, and again, most often in confused and obscure disputes. Fast forward to today, there have been at least 71 different rival international tendencies claiming the mantle of Trotskyism, with at least 35 still in existence (according to comrade Markov’s research). And each of these currents would proclaim themselves to be the real continuity of Trotskyism, against all other ‘revisionists.’ These are the symptoms of a movement in crisis, which we must understand if we are to claim to unite revolutionary forces today.”

At one level this is a perfectly reasonable point: the notion that any literal continuity of ‘pure’ Trotskyism exists today, or could exist, by some process of laying on of hands from generation to generation, is an idealist fantasy given that even the best of these political forces represented a complex political admixture derived from different trends. Every real movement has that character. The question is not of one of literal continuity, but rather of what should be the correct attitude of Marxists to any given political question that occurs, and also, since no question occurs in isolation, to a variety of questions both in their contemporary interaction as well as their successive sequential interactions. In that sense, everything is up for discussion, but this is not an idle matter of abstract debate, but a matter of theory and history as a guide to action. The only purpose of such debates can be to strengthen our political understanding of the questions we have to deal with today, to formulate a correct revolutionary practice going forward. He/she who fails to learn from history is doomed to repeat it, as comrade David in his own way points out. He makes a very good case that the ICFI was as egregiously Stalinophobic – itself a form of capitulation to imperialism –  as the Pabloites were liquidationist toward Stalinism, and the combination of the two was the germ of the extreme fragmentation of the Trotskyist left. One key lesson of this is that at any point in time, getting things right is crucial not just for now but for the future, and conversely getting things wrong can have adverse effects long into the future.

“Campism” vs Third Campism

To extend this discussion to Ukraine, comrade David writes, in a section subtitled “The ‘Theory of Blocs’”:

“…During the Cold War, the global class struggle was objectively refracted through the concrete antagonism between U.S. imperialism and the Soviet bloc—just as today, it is refracted through the antagonism between the U.S. and China. This does not mean class struggle ceases to exist within these blocs. Social reality is made of multiple layers. But to deny that the world consisted of a struggle between the imperialist and Soviet camps in the name of a ‘pure’ bourgeois-versus-worker line of battle leads immediately to ‘Third Campism,’ which always ends up capitulating to imperialism.”

The formulation about China is one-sided, and too hasty to shuffle away the USSR (or what remains of it, which is mainly Russia and Belarus) from this antagonism. Though it is correct to say that China, as a giant deformed workers’ state, is the West’s primary antagonist, it is not their exclusive antagonist. The antagonism of the Western bourgeoisie, on both sides of the Atlantic, for Russia is if anything now more vehement than when the USSR was still a workers’ state, i.e., before 1991. This is because they perceive that the counterrevolution is incomplete, the neoliberal shock that was supposed to bury the workers state once-and-for-all, has been rolled back, that Putin is a creature of the old USSR apparatus in spite of his non-communist formal beliefs, and that Russia’s mixed economy (over 50% state owned) is a travesty of what they would expect from capitalist restoration (a ‘socialist’ deformation, so to speak).

Above all, for all the Western fulminations about Putin being allegedly a ‘dictator’, he does allow various Western pollsters and the like to survey the Russian population, and those agencies tell them that Putin does have massive support among the Russian population, for his rollback of the murderous neoliberal shock treatment that Yeltsin and the neoliberal West imposed on Russia in the 1990s. They see Belarus as an even more horrible example of a stalled counterrevolution – ‘capitalism’ with huge ‘socialist’ deformations, in a sense the dialectical mirror image of a deformed workers state, with a new form of combined and uneven development involving the intertwining of capitalist and post-capitalist modes of production.

Western bourgeois hatred of Russia has transformed from old-style Cold War anti-communism, which professed to be ‘democratic’ and ethnically neutral, to a virulent Russophobia today, where Russian people and culture are simply demonised. This actually bears resemblance to Hitler’s hatred of Jews. It is worth remembering that Hitler’s Jew-hatred was predicated on the delusion that Jews were intrinsically, organically inclined to ‘subversion’, and were the source of Marxism and Bolshevism. Zionism has cured that delusion among the bourgeoisie. Instead, we have the belief that Russians are intrinsically inclined to disobedience to neoliberalism’s categorical imperatives – ‘subversive’ and communist in effect –  and that Hitler was right to hate and massacre Russians (though not Jews). That is the belief system that is behind Western imperialist anti-Russian hatred and their arming of open Nazis in Ukraine who glory in Hitler’s Operation Barbarossa, to kill Russians and Russian-speakers. Much mainstream Western anti-Russian propaganda today resembles Nazi Anti-Jewish hatred, and it has infected part of the left.

The different attitude of Trump to Russia is a product of his own position as a de-facto hireling of Israel and Likud in particular, whose billionaire Adelson dynasty paid for his three election campaigns so that he could wage war against Iran on their behalf, which Biden, Obama and earlier GW Bush and the Clintons refused to do. The Zionists are well aware that the declining US does not have the resources to do both. The “Russiagate” conspiracy theory that Trump is somehow a Kremlin agent was (and is) a cowardly means of the US bourgeois mainstream to try to combat this Israeli interference in US politics without naming who is actually responsible, which would cause a huge crisis in intra-imperialist politics, which is on the verge of happening anyhow because of Trump’s defeat at the hands of Iran.

There is a major contradiction between comrade David’s partial defence of the ‘Theory of Blocs’ as put forward by Pablo, and this passage about Ukraine in the document from the ICL’s 9th International Conference:

“This is the central flaw of ‘campism.’ It rejects proletarian independence as the guiding thread of the anti-imperialist struggle and supports any force opposed to the U.S. and its allies, regardless of its class character or policies. Under this logic, states such as Russia and the Islamic Republic of Iran, or alliances like BRICS+ are treated as progressive poles of resistance simply because they present a challenge to U.S. dominance. This logic of lesser-evilism ends up excusing the crimes and oppression carried out by such forces on the grounds that they weaken a rival.

“The implications of this approach are disastrous. Siding with Russia in the Ukraine war, for example, on the basis that it is fighting a NATO proxy accepts and legitimizes the national oppression of Ukrainians as a lesser evil in the struggle against U.S. imperialism. This further divides the working class in Eastern Europe, binding it to its respective rulers, thus obstructing its revolutionary unity against the dominant forces responsible for the current status quo in the region: the U.S., EU and NATO.” (https://iclfi.org/spartacist/en/71/unite)

Regarding Russia, this is actually a wobble away from the correct points comrade David made about the ‘theory of blocs’, cited earlier. It could be updated thus:

“ … the anti-imperialist struggle, which the proletariat must champion for its own class reasons, is objectively refracted through the concrete antagonism between imperialism and Russia (and ultimately China). This does not mean class struggle ceases to exist within these blocs. Social reality is made of multiple layers. But to deny that the world consists of a struggle between the imperialist and anti-imperialist camps in the name of a ‘pure’ bourgeois-versus-worker line of battle leads immediately to ‘Third Campism,’ which always ends up capitulating to imperialism.”

There is no evidence that Russia is fighting today for the national oppression of Ukraine. It is fighting against the national and language-based oppression of the Russian-speaking people of the South-Eastern half of what was Ukraine, centred on the Donbass. That oppression began with the far-right Maidan coup, instituted by the US-funded National Endowment for Democracy in 2014, with a bloody ‘anti-terrorist operation’ against Russian-speaking citizens in the Donbass who did not consent to be governed by a Neo-Nazi regime bent on stamping out their language. This was accompanied by massacres by Ukrainian Nazis of Russian-speakers in places like Odessa, outside the Donbass. Russian troops have fought in the mainly Russian speaking areas of Ukraine, and have not sought to conquer the Ukrainian-speaking West. 

They are making steady but excellent progress in painstakingly defeating the fascist occupiers of the Donbass, and rebuilding towns and cities that were hugely damaged by the Nazis – Mariupol being a prime example. The real logic of this war is a comprehensive partition of Ukraine along language lines, possibly with some special arrangement for Kiev, which is more mixed. This is the consequence of trying to supress the native language of around half the population. There is no evidence that Russia aims to conquer and rule Western Ukraine. There is a possibility that Poland and perhaps Romania/Moldova may step in when Ukraine loses the war and take back territory that is historically Polish or Romanian-speaking, but that is nothing to do with Russia. Denazification and demilitarisation of Ukraine clearly means an Austria-like status for a rump, neutral Ukraine. That is just as reasonable for Russia as the expulsion of US bases from the Persian Gulf is for Iran.

The Russian People and Oppression

Many Russian nationalists, including Putin, are critical of the early Bolsheviks for including overwhelmingly Russian and Russian-speaking areas like the Donbass and Odessa in the early Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic. In the light of today, they have a point, as with the counterrevolution, those populations became oppressed. It is clear that other means would have been better . Putin’s other criticisms seem doubtful. Such as if matters had been addressed differently, Ukrainian might have been seen as merely a dialect and absorbed into Russian the way such dialects as Provençal or Picard were into French. That is far less convincing.

Odessa Trade Union House massacre: May 2nd 2014 by Ukrainian Nazis
 

There is no evidence, contrary to Western propaganda, that Putin aims to reconquer a Great Russian empire. In fact, Putin appears to be a lesser-Russian nationalist, akin to Atatürk. The stereotype of Russians as arch-imperialists is reactionary and should not be indulged, even when it appears on the left, as from the social-imperialist contemporary United Secretariat, who just echo NATO and Western imperialism. Russian imperialism ceased in 1917, and was problematic even then in some ways as Trotsky pointed out in his History of the Russian Revolution:

“India participated in the war both essentially and formally as a colony of England. The participation of China, though in a formal sense ‘voluntary,’ was in reality the interference of a slave in the fight of his masters. The participation of Russia falls somewhere halfway between the participation of France and that of China. Russia paid in this way for her right to be an ally of advanced countries, to import capital and pay interest on it – that is, essentially, for her right to be a privileged colony of her allies – but at the same time for her right to oppress and rob Turkey, Persia, Galicia, and in general the countries weaker and more backward than herself. The twofold imperialism of the Russian bourgeoisie had basically the character of an agency for other mightier world powers.” (https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1930/hrr/ch02.htm)

This was the feeblest manifestation of imperialism, the weak link that did not survive the first imperialist war before being torn out by the roots by the victorious proletariat – mainly that of Russia. In the aftermath of the revolution, Soviet Russia was invaded by 13 different imperialist armies. That invasion was followed 22 years later by Hitler’s bloody counterrevolutionary assault. All these events make it entirely reasonable to regard Russians as a population (indirectly) oppressed by Western imperialism, not an incorrigible oppressor people, despite all the crimes of Stalinism. That is the purpose of the plan behind the West’s anti-Russian drive, as laid out in Brzezinski’s Grand Chessboard design – the breakup of Russia and its subordination to Western imperialism.

The image of Russia and the Russian people as habitual Great Russian imperialists, striving to conquer Europe, is a reactionary myth. Oppressive Russian nationalism was indeed a problem to be dealt with by the Bolsheviks, and there was a revival of that with the degeneration of the revolution under Stalinism, but administrative attempts to dilute the influence of the Russian population by placing portions of that population in new non-Russian republics, in the light of hindsight, might not have been the best way to deal with this national question. Nothing is above questioning or reconsideration in the light of historical experience. And Trotskyists should have no truck with third campism today any more than in 1953, as comrade David rightly pointed out about the earlier case. We cannot rearm the proletariat, either in the West, or Russia and Ukraine for that matter, for proletarian revolution without confronting the reactionary role of Russophobia and third-campism today.

Holborn and St Pancras By-Election: For a Spoilt Ballot!

In the Holborn and St Pancras (HSP) By-Election, there is currently no Labour or left-wing candidate that is sufficiently on the side of the working class and the oppressed to merit electoral support from those communists who are concerned, as Marx and Engels’ Manifesto of the Communist Party says, to “represent the interests of the [working class] movement as a whole”.

In order to merit critical support, a non-communist candidate has to have something that they stand for that is unambiguously positive from the standpoint of the working class, even though the communist minority may very well suspect that they will betray such policies or promises if elected. The point of the tactic of critical support is to exploit some kind of contradiction between a claim to stand for the working class and the oppressed, and their real politics and deeds.

There are three contenders for such critical support in HSP. They are – Sagal Abdi-Wali, the Labour Party candidate, George Galloway, the Workers Party (WP) candidate and indeed WP leader, and Zack Polanski, the Green Party (GP) candidate and also GP leader.

There are fundamental problems with all three, not abstractly but concretely, in the current context. Abdi-Wali is the leader of Camden Council and, though she is of Somali origin, is an unrepentant supporter of Keir Starmer. Notwithstanding the traitorous Zionist and arch enemy of the Corbynite left being driven out of Downing Street and replaced by Andy Burnham, Burnham’s words about how Labour “got it wrong” after October 7th 2023, and even Ed Miliband’s supposed sanctions against Zionist settlers in the West Bank, Labour at its conference is still arresting people for protesting against genocide, using the fraudulent proscription of Palestine Action for ‘terrorism’ as a fig-leaf. Meanwhile, the real neo-Nazi terrorist movement Patriot Platform, whose masked thugs have been terrorising the streets of cities like Dover and Portsmouth, are not proscribed, but their thugs are free to threaten all opponents of the far right. Opposition to electoral support to Burnham’s Labour is a no-brainer.

Then there is George Galloway, and his Workers Party. He has some very good positions, on opposing Zionism and opposing NATO’s proxy war against Russia over Ukraine. If these were only what he was known for, it would be correct not just to just advocate a vote for him, but to actively get involved in the campaign. But he also stands for ‘Stop the Boats’. In the Runcorn and Helsby by-election of May 2025, WP candidate and Deputy Leader Peter Ford stood on the slogans “Stop the Boats” and “Tough on Immigration, Tough on the Causes of Immigration”. This by-election was won by Reform at the most dangerous point (so far) of the far-right wave assisted by this very right-wing ‘Labour government’. Instead of fighting against the reactionary tide, Galloway’s party tried to swim with it. With miserable results – Ford got only 0.5% of the vote in a by-election where Reform defeated Starmer’s Labour by just 6 votes.

Galloway’s own statement for the HSP by election states, in attacking the Greens, says “Instead of addressing poverty, immigration, energy prices, they were voting together last week to introduce legislation to make killing people legal. We believe voters will welcome the chance to reject this madness.” We don’t share the Green Party’s support for the (defeated) Assisted Dying Bill, but we do not consider “addressing” “immigration” – that is, targeting migrant workers for repression and exclusion, to be the job of a working-class party. Our job, on the contrary, is to defend the rights of, and promote solidarity with, migrant workers and refugees. This is criticism of this foul government from the right, and makes a mockery of the correct criticisms the WP makes of the NATO/Zionist atrocities in the Donbass and Gaza. And with the masked fascist attacks on migrant workers, this issue is centre-stage, and has been ever since Labour was elected. We cannot give any support to a party that stands on such an anti-immigrant platform.

Then there is the Green Party. This is not even a working-class party – it is a party of the radical middle class; it does not orient to the labour movement. It doesn’t have a solid base of outright bourgeois support either; it represents a social layer that is capable either of following the working class or the bourgeoisie. It is a party of protest against the environmental destruction that capitalism brings. Whether it attributes this to capitalism is thus pretty important as to whether it has any potential to be won to the side of the working class. Recently the Greens in England and Wales have acquired a more left-wing reputation because of Polanski’s outspoken attacks on Israeli crimes. He actually publicly apologized to Corbyn for reactionary positions he took regarding the witchhunt in the Labour Party prior to the genocide, which is significant.  The failure of Your Party to organize the 800,000 who signed up a year ago as potential supporters of a new working-class socialist party allowed Polanski’s party to win over around 200,000 of those people with his leftist rhetoric particularly over Zionism. It also led the former independent candidate Andrew Feinstein, who stood against Starmer in this seat in the General Election, to call for votes to Polanski in this by-election, and then Chris Williamson, until recently a deputy leader of the Workers Party, to resign from that party in disagreement with Galloway’s decision to stand, and call for votes for Polanski also.

Both of them did so on the understanding that Polanski was supporting the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion at the coming Green Party conference. And in the case of Andrew Feinstein, he did so on the basis that Polanski endorsed the demands of the Camden People’s Alliance, the left-wing local independent umbrella group that Feinstein would have stood for before Polanski standing became a live issue.  But these were hardly challenging – mainly about local issues. After these endorsements, Polanski backed away from supporting the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion demanding extensive amendments to dilute it. Which led to criticism of Polanski, including from Chris Williamson. But there is an inherent problem in such support, in that it does nothing to address the question of the non-working-class nature of the Green Party, vague ‘left’ verbiage notwithstanding. The record of the Greens in local councils, in coalitions often with Liberal Democrats where they have regularly carried out austerity, is appalling.  However, because of the mass influx of erstwhile YP supporters, which quadrupled its membership, there is a potential class-based division in the Greens. A coherent working-class party could, if it were not simply able to stand itself, place some much more stringent demands on the Greens, as a possible lever to split them. This is what one of our comrades proposed in a motion in Croydon Your Party: three demands, on top of a decent position on “Zionism is racism”:

“(a) a clear statement from the GP that the root cause of the environmental crisis their party was set up to address, is capitalism, which therefore needs to be abolished.

“(b) That Zack Polanski and Your Party should issue a statement jointly defending Diane Abbot against the renewed witchhunting of her in the Labour Party, for her justified attack on NATO aggression as the cause of the war in Ukraine.

“(c) That the Greens should jointly with us and others in the labour movement, launch a trade union and community-centred campaign against the environmentally ruinous plans for AI Data Centres in numerous parts  of this country. And to encourage similar activities internationally.”

This was topped off with “This motion should be sent to the [Your Party] CEC for their attention.” Given the appalling disaster that the Corbyn leadership have made of the Party’s evident potential a year ago, placing these demands could have had a political impact. If they were to be accepted, it would have meant that the pro-socialist elements would be in the ascendancy in the Greens. Point 2 goes some way to counter the Greens’ reactionary position on the Ukraine War, and the others would mean a pro-working class, anti-capitalist agenda instead of illusions in ‘Green’ capitalism. This might be a long shot, but it could have been a way to try to pull away the numerous supporters lost to the Greens by YP back to a working-class project.

Without this being a realistic possibility, as is now clear, socialists and class-conscious workers in Holborn and St Pancras should spoil their ballots in this election.

BRICS: Multilateralist Illusions

Three steps back, when the moment of geopolitical conflict requires forward steps

Érico Cardoso

https://emancipacaodotrabalho.org/Publicacao.aspx?id=700480

 BRICS held its 18th Summit in New Delhi between 12 and 13 September 2026, under the presidency of India, with the participation of 10 of its 11 members. For a number of reasons, including the heterogeneous and unequal intertwining of the economies of its participating members with the economies of the imperialist system, the bloc, composed of dependent and semi-colonial capitalist states and China (a workers’ state), has set aside confrontational geopolitical narratives, believing that it will be able to focus on concrete deliveries and internal institutional strengthening.

The central theme was “Building Resilience, Innovation, Cooperation and Sustainability”. One cannot blame only the host nation and the political alignment of its right-wing, pro-US government for the disarming character of the Summit, this is also a reason, but not the only one. The bloc decided to take steps back, avoiding, as it has done in these 20 years of existence, forming itself into an instrument of organized resistance to the imperialist offensive, while the G-7 and company carry out a new arms race in Europe against Russia; the US and in the midst of the Zionist war against Iran, Palestine, Lebanon and Yemen; expansionism in Latin America; escalations that have as a strategy the defeat of the most powerful and developed adversary, China. Despite these “Western” offensives, the New Delhi summit retreated three crucial steps: 1. it began to bet on the recovery of multilateral organizations from the imperialist system to build its multilateralism; 2. If postponed again the creation of a common currency and 3. it barred the entry of new nations.

 Would it be possible to build a new multilateralism based on the reform of the multilateral organizations of the imperialist system?

 The New Delhi Declaration (with 140 points) reinforced the need to reform institutions such as the UN, WTO and IMF to reflect the multipolar reality. There was explicit condemnation of unilateral sanctions and coercive measures contrary to international law.

After World War II, the main imperialist nations were indebted or occupied by US bases. The main losers in the war, Germany, Italy and Japan became military colonies. This hegemony established the dollar as the standard currency of world market exchanges and a set of multilateral financial, commercial, civil and military organizations (WB, IMF, WTO, UN, NATO). This imperialist system entered into crisis during the financialization of the economy and the crisis of 2008. BRICS believes that an opportunity is opening up to promote a kind of democratic revitalization of the organisms that served the hegemony of the United States for 70 years and are now being abandoned by it.

The government representing the interests of US imperialism today despises the multilateral organizations of the imperialist system, which suffer economic disinvestment by the US that acts with ultrapotitism, punctual military alliances, reconcentration of forces in the Western Hemisphere (Donroe Doctrine) to prioritize the “America First” policy, seeking maximum freedom to override the entire international legal system and reduce US financial spending abroad and replace collective alliances with bilateral direct transaction agreements. In January 2026, Trump signed a proclamation determining the immediate withdrawal from the country of 66 international organizations, 31 of which are linked to the UN and 35 independent entities. According to the White House, these bodies act against American national interests.

No one can complain that Trump has not helped the BRICS, accentuating the isolation of the US and pushing other nations into the arms of China. This is the case of India itself, whose government prefers to be a vassal of the US, thinks it is an ally of Washington and feeds historical, economic and border rivalries with China, but has been pushed by Trumpist protectionism to ally itself with its Asian neighbour. A rapprochement that has strengthened in New Delhi, between Modi and Xi Jinping, thanks to the fact that India has been surprised and frustrated by the various tariff attacks and threats by the Trump administration since 2025, dispelling illusions about a supposed special partnership relationship with the US.

Postponing De-Dollarization and New Mechanisms Again

The summit abandoned the idea of a common BRICS currency, which was considered unfeasible. The strategy adopted is intended to be pragmatic. Payment interconnection – it seeks to connect systems such as UPI (India), Pix (Brazil), MIR (Russia) and CIPS (China) to make cross-border transactions cheaper. Settlement of bilateral transactions in local currencies: Stimulation of trade without going through the dollar, with possible savings of 2-3% in conversion costs. In addition to these mechanisms, they are betting on the BRICS Multilateral Guarantees, a pilot initiative of the New Development Bank (NDB) to attract private capital and reduce financing costs for infrastructure. The bloc’s countries have also adopted a multifaceted strategy to reduce dependence on SWIFT. The main collective mechanism used and in an advanced stage of implementation is BRICS Pay. BRICS Pay works as a decentralized digital infrastructure that connects the domestic payment systems already existing in the member countries. Instead of recreating a global network from scratch, it promotes the direct bridge between successful local platforms such as mo PIX, UPI, MIR and CIPS. These are all lateral measures, relatively timid, as long as an anti-dollar global currency could favor the breakdown of the financing of imperialism at this time of crisis of the petrodollar system due to the defeats of imperialism and Zionism in Southeast Asia.

The control of money and the banking system is not only a measure of monetary policy, but a fundamental political weapon and strategy for the anti-imperialist struggle. Despite copying or re-editing initiatives of the post-war imperialist system, such as industrialization, multilateral organizations, and the expansion of the global market, BRICS has not been consistent in the establishment of a new standard currency that serves to supplant the dollar, a very important mechanism of imperialism’s exchange hegemony over the world economy. The main accelerating motivation for de-dollarization is the need for geopolitical security. When the United States and its allies froze about $300 billion in Russia’s foreign exchange reserves in 2022 due to the war in Ukraine, it became clear to BRICS members that dependence on the dollar represents a sovereignty risk. Countries fear that, in any future diplomatic conflicts, they may also be cut off from the Western financial system (such as the SWIFT payment mechanism). Currently, if Brazil sells products to China, the transaction often needs to convert Reais to Dollars and then Dollars to Yuan. This process involves duplicate bank fees and risks of currency fluctuation. By establishing local currencies or a common unit of account for international trade, countries reduce costs and increase the efficiency of trade exchanges within the bloc.

With the Anglo-Saxon tech giants (Bigtech) that control much of the world’s communications and information traffic on the other side, the summit made the debate around technology a central pillar, focusing on digital sovereignty and the right to development of the countries of the Global South. The declaration on Global Governance of AI was the bloc’s first consensus document on the subject, expressing the intention to reduce technological dependence on Bigtech and supporting the creation of the Digital Public Infrastructure Library (DPI), for sharing good practices and interoperability between members’ digital systems. Getting lost in reunionism without the necessary steps that the geopolitical dispute requires at the moment, they settle for administrative measures that fall short of what is needed, creating, for example, in the midst of the annual rotation of the presidency, a Continuity and Implementation mechanism to monitor initiatives via the Troika (previous, current and next presidency), with a digital repository to monitor deadlines and status and an Emergency Support Network for Seafarers to coordinate assistance (medical, evacuation, communication with family members) to seafarers in crisis situations.

Containing Its Own Expansion

Today, the real weight of the BRICS stems more from its existence itself than from its willingness to be an alternative to the imperialist bloc, an aspiration that its members who adhere to a worsened version of the policy of “peaceful coexistence” of the twentieth century do not have.

The weight of BRICS stems from the size of its members. It includes the two most populous countries on the planet (India and China); three of the five largest countries in territorial extension (Russia, China and Brazil); and five of the largest economies in the world (China, India, Russia, Indonesia and Brazil). Another striking feature – the group includes the three countries that are in confrontation with the collective West – China, Russia and Iran. The activity of BRICS is followed with concern in Washington and in European capitals. Donald Trump has threatened BRICS several times, trying to scare the most fearful or most vulnerable members of the group. (DCM, The BRICS summit in India: political and financial results).

After the wave of new members, which brought the institution to 11 members (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa, Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, Indonesia, United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia) the Indian summit chose to pause the formal expansion to consolidate internal mechanisms. More than 20 countries that have already expressed interest in joining the bloc are thus vetoed, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Thailand, Vietnam, Bolivia, Venezuela, Algeria, Cuba, Nigeria and Uganda.

The focus has shifted to strengthening the network of partner countries (such as Vietnam) and practical cooperation in areas such as food security, energy, and health. The bloc has temporarily pulled the handbrake instead of expanding its cooperation to the areas of defense and security. As a historical leader of the Brazilian PT, Markus Sokol, aptly summarized, “there is a search among the peoples for a global alternative to the system in crisis, but this alternative is not BRICS, which does not want more than that, to accompany the world order in crisis” (OT Newspaper, 970).

 For a consistent anti-imperialist struggle

 In short, the New Delhi summit consolidated the BRICS as a bloc that, instead of seeking confrontation or even organized common resistance, believes it is prioritizing the construction of its own technical and financial infrastructure to increase the resilience and autonomy of the Global South. Capitalist aspirations that decadent imperialism sabotages and literally bombs, nothing preventing the system from dragging humanity into a new world war and a barbarism with no return, in full flight, slaughtering multilateralist illusions in full flight.

The resolutions of the New Delhi summit fall short of the recent victories of the oppressed nations over imperialism in the wars won in Afghanistan or still in progress: Ukraine and Iran. Victories that were only feared possible thanks to the bilateral and trilateral articulations between Russia, China, Iran and North Korea, in military coalitions formed more by a kind of antagonistic cooperation against an aggressive common enemy than by a common strategy for the defeat of imperialism by nations that are victims of it.

Although the official list of full members of the group has 11 countries, Saudi Arabia was on the official agendas of the New Delhi Summit, but did not confirm the sending of a presidential delegation to the main debates. In addition to these full members, the meeting in India brought together 10 other countries as new official “partner countries” of the bloc. It is worth noting that Saudi Arabia is being defeated once again by the Yemeni Houthi guerrillas, supported by Iran. The US could have been left with only the defeat in the Persian Gulf to Iran, but it decided to push Saudi Arabia to the precipice and now it screwed with the defences of the Arabian Peninsula, the traffic of the Red Sea, the passage through the Bab al Mandab, the petrodollar system, they screwed everything.

Despite the recent victories of some of its members over imperialism, the BRICS have proved incapable of defending key nations from the geopolitical dispute such as Venezuela, Cuba, Colombia, Bolivia, Peru, Argentina and Chile. For this reason, we believe that the tactic of taking steps backwards is a strategic mistake. It means abandoning all of Latin America to its fate, letting imperialism continue to advance in its backyard, appropriating inputs that today are vital for China itself and that once in the hands of imperialism will grant it a life, not to mention the cost of this offensive for Latin American workers.

Finally, it is important to understand that the tariff, military and technological victories obtained by the “Global South” have recently been possible thanks to the crisis of the imperialist Military-Industrial Complex, with overpriced weapons and in loss of power of domination given the deindustrialization that the imperialist system is going through. Private capital in the era of financialization is more parasitic and rentier than ever. Therefore, in order to develop their national economies, oppressed peoples and countries need to decouple their economies from the imperialist system, and bet on the industrialization and nationalization of their economies, not feeding illusions in Public-Private Partnerships or in the illusion that the G20 is “the main global forum for international economic cooperation to provide a platform for dialogue between emerging and developed economies in conditions of equality and mutual benefit”.

Imperialism attacks but loses ground in the three continents of the old world, while maintaining a consistent advance by recolonizing the American continent under the Donroe doctrine. A situation that proves that the consequent anti-imperialist struggle depends on the responsibility placed on the shoulders of the working class and the proletarian internationalism of the oppressed peoples.

Red Partisan 3 out now!

The lead article in this issue focusses on the environmental crisis that became glaringly obvious this summer, with the repeated heatwaves that undoubtedly were the cause of much loss of life, record-breaking overall temperature globally and the unmistakeable fact that this is the product of anthropogenic climate change, which is above all the product of the capitalist mode of production. This ought to be, if the world was rational, the most pressing and urgent issue of all for humanity to deal with. But the cause of it is, as mentioned, the capitalist mode of production, and the struggle against other concrete manifestations of that, from imperialist war to the class struggle within the imperialist countries, also holds centre stage. What we as revolutionary Marxist have to do is to find a way to integrate this understanding of the existential nature of the environmental struggle into the class consciousness we are seeking to promote as the antithesis of capitalism in movements of workers and the oppressed more generally.

The other lead article in this issue is an analysis of the rise to the premiership of Andy Burnham, and why he in particular was chosen to replace Starmer when the reactionary and Zionist forces that promoted Starmer to destroy the Corbyn project, concluded that Starmer’s many vices were leading the Labour Party to destruction. There is also an article on the prominent role of Burnham and Starmer in the accelerating, and quite demented, drive of the West European imperialist bourgeoisies in seeking some kind of existential confrontation with Russia now that it is increasingly clear that Nazi-Maidan Ukraine is on the verge of collapse despite all the many billions that its imperialist sponsors have expended on it. And there is a brief commentary on the Holborn and St Pancras by-election, where the Green Party’s Zack Polanski is fighting to win Starmer’s former seat against Labour, but George Galloway has decided to stand also for the Workers Party (WP). This prompted the resignation of WP Deputy Leader Chris Williamson from the WP in disagreement with Galloway’s action.

The article proposed a possible way to place demands on Polanski, as the leader of a non-working class, petty-bourgeois radical party, to embrace key elements of working-class politics as a precondition for any kind of electoral support, as a possible tactic to bring to the fore the tens of thousands of socialist-minded militants who have joined the Greens because of the dramatic failure of the Corbyn-misled Your Party to give expression to their aspirations. Since this was written, Polanski has backed away from supporting the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion that the left-wing of the Greens were trying to get passed, aiming to make the Greens the only overtly anti-Zionist party contending in mainstream British politics (Your Party is hardly ‘contending’ at the moment). Polanski’s retreat on this has prompted criticism from Chris Williamson, among others, and may come to be seen as a significant moment among those seeking a new working class, socialist party.

Other significant material in this issue includes an account of the political degeneration of the Socialist Federation. This was originally conceived as the Members’ Charter, an initiative to try to force democratisation in Your Party, but has now, thanks to the influence of pro-NATO, Ziophile social imperialists like ‘Anti-Capitalist Resistance’, turned it into a strange heresy-hunting project. It had to postpone its own Founding Conference because its fratricidal warfare made such an event unfeasible. That takes some doing! Many of the remaining socialist activists in Your Party treat it with deep suspicion therefore.

There is also an account of the Founding Conference of the British Chapter of the Anti-Fascist International; the Consistent Democrats are one of its supporting groups. It is a campaigning anti-imperialist, anti-fascist body that was originally an initiative of the Maduro government in Venezuela, prior to his outrageous abduction by Trump. Included is the text of a speech by one of our comrades to this conference, on Zionism and the sinister, genocidal nature and purpose of the so-called “IHRA definition” of Anti-Semitism. And there is a brief statement of our position on the recent UNITE General Secretary election.

All in all, this issue has material that should be of interest to a wide range of socialists and working-class activists.

Speech at Anti-Fascist International Conference

(by Ian Donovan for Consistent Democrats)

I want to raise the subject of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of Anti-Semitism as a matter for comrades to think about at this conference. This became a prominent issue in this country in the period when the Labour Party was led by Jeremy Corbyn. It was used as a weapon to undermine him, because of his reputation as a defender of Palestinians. It deliberately re-writes the definition of anti-semitism from racial hatred, to a mixture of what could be called ‘political crimes.’ First of all, in the bare-bones definition it broadens the supposed target of anti-Semitism from just Jews as individuals of a supposed ‘race’, to “Jewish community institutions and religious facilities”

There then follow a series of eleven ‘illustrations’ of what that might mean. Some are largely consistent with racial hostility – such as denying the holocaust, or suggesting it was not intentional, or was exaggerated. Or suggesting that “the Jews killed Jesus”. But most of these ‘illustrations’ refer in some way to Israel. Indeed, of the eleven, only the first four do not refer to Israel. The rest, even ones that refer obliquely to genocide denial, bring Israel into the argument. But at the time that the genocide of Jews took place, Israel did not exist. And it is a fact that at least some Zionists can be validly accused of collaborating with the Nazis. So, what it this document about? It is not about defining racism against Jews as people. It is about organisations. And it’s clear that the organisation it is concerned with protecting most of all, is the Israeli state. After the first four, which are indeed arguably about racism against Jews, all the remaining seven drag in the question of Israel. It’s a form of ‘gaslighting’. Another word for that is an amalgam. Mixing two completely different things up and claiming they are the same thing. A dreadful technique whenever it occurs.

 For instance, it says that this is anti-Semitism: “Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavour.” There a little diversion in this. They say “a state of Israel” and not “the State of Israel”. As if some other state of Israel existed somewhere in a parallel universe that did not expel three quarters of the Palestinian Arab people in 1948. Of course, they mean the real Israel, not a fictional one! Then there is “Applying double standards by requiring of it a behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.” But how can a country that expels the majority of its indigenous population, be called a ‘democratic nation’? Obviously, it cannot! And then there is “Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.” But what are Nazis known for? Genocide!

So, this says it is ‘anti-Semitic’ to accuse Israel of intending to commit genocide against the Palestinians. That is clearly a pro-genocide scam. This fake ‘definition’ was first published, as a ‘working definition’ in 2005, as the European Union Centre on Racism and Xenophobia (EUMC)’s definition. That was in the context of growing anti-Zionist sentiment largely because of the very visible role of Zionist neocons in pushing for the attack on Iraq. The EUMC abandoned it in 2016 after a considerable outcry. And so, the IHRA took it up. A bloc of Israel and a whole bunch of its allies. But its purpose has always been to excuse Israel’s genocidal tendencies. They wouldn’t need to smear people who pointed out the similarity of Israel’s behaviour to the Nazis, if Israel didn’t behave like — the Nazis.

In other words, both those who formulated this fake definition, and those who it was aimed at persecuting, knew that Israel had genocidal tendencies. The aim of the gaslighting, of the amalgam that is built into this, was always to suppress criticism of Israel’s genocidal nature, and therefore to prepare the political conditions where Israel could commit genocide of the Palestinians, with impunity. So, this document, the IHRA definition, can be called a ‘warrant for genocide’ of the Palestinians. Just as the Tsarist forgery, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, was a warrant for genocide of the Jews by Hitler. It was used to purge the Labour Party of opponents of such a crime, so that Labour could support the genocide, which Starmer did. Trump is using it to persecute opponents of Israel’s genocide, trying to deport non-citizen students for supposed ‘anti-Semitism’. And in terms of the response of the Western countries, Israel is  getting away with the genocide. So far Holland, Spain, Ireland, Iceland, Belgium and Turkey, of Western countries, have accused Israel of genocide.  But none of the major countries in West Europe and North America have done so.

The IHRA definition is being used here to persecute opponents of Israel’s genocide, in the NHS, in universities, and anywhere else they can get away with it. There is now considerable pushback against it. The BMA is opposing it. As are some universities. This fake definition, used for this purpose, is a threat to us all. It needs to be consigned to the same pit of infamy as the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

Burnham/Starmer, Europe and the drive to war against Russia

Starmer’s regime, and now Burnham’s, has carried on and intensified the actions of the previous Sunak/Truss/ Johnson regime in sending Storm Shadow missiles to Ukraine, for the Zelensky-Nazi regime to fire into Russia with obvious British technical and intelligence data to guide them. This could not be done without the active involvement of British military personnel, as the Russian government was always well aware. Far from being the military adventurist that Western imperialist propaganda claims, Putin has been extremely cautious and restrained in confronting this kind of provocative activity. By sticking rigidly to the strict territorial objectives of the campaign of attrition Russia has waged against the occupation of Donbass territory, Russia is on the brink of victory. The Maidan regime staggers on the brink of collapse, having coerced millions of its own citizens into unwillingly marching into a meat grinder, which may have killed millions of such forced conscripts in a dirty war to hang onto territory whose population does not want to be ruled by Kiev.

Burnham with Zelensky in Ukraine in August 

The standard tactic of the Ukrainian Nazi regime when being forced to surrender a town or village is to demand that the population leave with them, or be murdered. Many have in fact been  murdered trying to hide in basements from the killer battalions, with the Russian army often making grisly discoveries when they take control. This is how the Russophone Ukrainian population of East Ukraine is treated by the Nazi regime, for whom speaking Russian is a crime worthy of death. It’s also why the mere liberation of the four provinces currently being fought over is not going to be sufficient to end the war. A realistic objective is the liberation of more than a third of present-day Ukraine, roughly on a diagonal line between just to the West of Odessa, linking up with Transnistria, the Russian-speaking rebel enclave of Moldova that is close to Odessa, skirting Kyiv and extending to the Kharkov oblast. This partition is the logic of the abolition of constitutional language equality by the Kyiv regime after Maidan in 2024.

As Russia has got closer and closer to outright victory in the Donbass , the level of hysterical Russophobia from the British bourgeoisie, as well as the other main West European imperialists, France and Germany, and the weak, vassal ruling classes in several of the weak bourgeois states in East Europe that have been absorbed into the European Union and become vassals of the main EU states, has risen to a crescendo of hatred and warmongering frenzy. The West-European bourgeoisies are actively seeking ways to wage war against Russia. They continually claim that they expect Russia to attack Western Europe by around 2030 or 2035, depending on which war narrative you read, and demand draconian cuts in social spending throughout Europe to pay for rearmament to confront and fight a war with Russia. The demand is for arms spending to rapidly rise to at least 5% of GBP over the next several years, but at the same time some of their most virulent elements keep raising demands for action now, for greater use of Western weapons and more drone terrorism by Ukraine against Russian civilians in towns and cities, or attacks on strategic economic or military assets, to provoke Russia into an armed response. This has a crazed aspect, that is causing alarm across the continent, and is provoking political dissent from some on both the left and the right.

The West European bourgeoisies are hysterical about Russia under Putin having refused to simply knuckle under to the Western diktat to privatise and subordinate its economy to the neoliberal ethos, which was proceeding apace under Yeltsin in the 1990s, an epoch which impoverished the Russian population and reduced Russia to 14th economic ranking in terms of GPD PPP. Today in the same terms, Russia’s economy is ranked 4th, and it has achieved this by not being an appendage of the West, but by de-facto, an evolving alliance with the giant deformed workers state of China, as well as Iran, in BRICS. Iran being the central nation involved in resisting the Greater Israel project in West Asia – Israel being a key, discrete imperialist power within the Western alliance of imperialist states with its own interests, which uses its independent ‘lobbying’ power among the bourgeoisies of the West to push hard for those interests within those imperialist alliances. Under Biden and Obama’s presidencies, a very similar strategy was pursed by the United States – the Maidan coup was pushed through in Ukraine by the Obama administration, and Biden as President was as provocatively anti-Russian as any of the Europeans, provoking the Special Military Operation in 2022 by pushing the Maidan regime into a major attack on the Donetsk and Lugansk People’s Republics, as the current Donetsk and Lugansk provinces of the Russian Federation were then called after rebelling against the Western sponsored Nazi-Maidan coup in 2014. This was extensively reported on at the time by the courageous Swiss former OSCE Official Jacques Baud, who is now being ‘sanctioned’ by the Western powers for his dissent in a similar manner to the equally courageous and outspoken opponent of Israel’s genocide and UN Special Rapporteur, Francesca Albanese. Biden initiated the supply of US ATACMS missiles to Ukraine for firing into Russia itself, which, like Storm Shadow, needed US personnel to target and operate them, which the Russians were and are fully aware of.

The main reason why the Trump administration has demurred from this approach somewhat, both in his first (2017 to 2021) term and this one from 2025 onwards, has been because of Trump being qualitatively more subservient to Israel than previous presidents. For him, full commitment to the proxy war in Ukraine was counterposed to his project of deepening US collaboration with Israel in order to attack Iran, which no previous US President was prepared to go through with, and it was clear that the US in decline was no longer able to supply two such major wars at the same time. Now that the attack on Iran has come unstuck, and the US has suffered a major, strategic defeat in West Asia over this attack, there has been something of a swing back to at least a posture by the Trump administration of more aggression against Russia, more in tune with the Europeans. But it is somewhat hollow, as the depletion of US stocks of important missiles and other munitions, and its more general failures, have also affected its ability to be effective in the Ukraine proxy war as this failure has done elsewhere. Like the US taking THAAD missile defence systems from South Korea, where they were aimed at China and North Korea, and sending them to West Asia where a number of such facilities have been destroyed by Iran, has adversely affected the US’s ability to confront China. Which in a way is all to the good, but it does underline the contradictions of Washington’s aggression on behalf of Israel, and how it has accelerated the US decline.